Middle Island, NY Dentists

Compare 5 dental offices in Middle Island, NY (Suffolk County). Read 682 Google reviews, with an average rating of 4.30 stars.

Last updated Aug 31, 2026 · How we rank →

5
Dental offices ranked
4.30 avg
Google rating (vs 4.46 NY)
3
With ratings
682
Combined Google reviews
60%
Have a website
1
Score 96+ (Elite)

How we rank · independent Dental.me Score · Featured is separate and cannot buy rank.

Dentists in Middle Island, NY — ranked

Showing 1–5 of 5
Score tiers: Elite 96+ Excellent 91–95 Great 86–90 Strong 80–85 Good 70–79 Fair
📖 New to the area? Read our complete guide to finding a dentist in Middle Island — costs, specialties, and what to look for.

The Middle Island dental market, by the numbers

How Middle Island’s 5 dental offices compare.

Dental.me Score distribution

How Middle Island’s rated offices spread across score tiers.

Elite 96+1
Excellent0
Great0
Strong1
Good & below1

Rating vs. New York

Average Google rating across rated Middle Island offices.

4.30
Middle Island average4.30 ★
New York average4.46 ★
Rated 4.9–5.02 offices
Elite (96+) offices1

Middle Island dental leaders

Compare the highest scores and the most Google reviews.

Highest Dental.me Score

Top of the independent, non-paid ranking.

  1. Alan Ellman - Harvey Lindenbaum DDS
    Score 98 · 4.9 ★ · 679 reviews
  2. Tamer Barsom
    Score 84 · 5.0 ★ · 1 reviews
  3. Total Dental Care of Middle Island P.C.
    Score 60 · 3.0 ★ · 2 reviews

Most reviewed offices

Largest Google review counts in Middle Island.

  1. Tamer Barsom
    1 reviews · 5.0 ★

Dental.me guides for Middle Island

These guides help you compare Middle Island dentists, understand treatment choices and plan for costs and insurance.

Guide links connect this city directory to the broader New York and national Dental.me research library. Organic rankings use Dental.me Score; Featured placements stay separate from the ranked list.

Nearby cities

Nearby cities with dentists, by distance from Middle Island.

More dentists in New York

Explore nearby cities and types of care, or browse all New York dentists.

New York cities to compare

Types of dental care across the state

Each office page has website, map and phone links to help you discuss care, insurance and payment.

Common questions about dentists in Middle Island

Who are the highest-rated dentists in Middle Island, NY?

By Dental.me Score, the top-rated Middle Island dentists are Alan Ellman - Harvey Lindenbaum DDS (Dental.me Score 98, 4.9 stars, 679 reviews); Tamer Barsom (Dental.me Score 84, 5.0 stars, 1 reviews); Total Dental Care of Middle Island P.C. (Dental.me Score 60, 3.0 stars, 2 reviews). Across the city, 2 offices are rated 4.9 to 5.0. The ranked list above updates as new review data comes in.

Are dentists in Middle Island, NY good?

Middle Island's rated dental offices average 4.30 stars on Google - compared with a 4.46 New York average, and 2 are rated 4.9 to 5.0. The Dental.me Score ranks them by star-rating strength and review volume so you can compare the strongest offices first.

What dental categories are common in Middle Island, NY?

Common Dental.me categories connected to Middle Island profiles include Cosmetic Dentists, Emergency Dentists, Endodontists, Periodontists, Dental Implants. Category data helps organize local options and gives patients a faster way to compare offices by the type of care they are researching.

How many dentists are in Middle Island, NY?

Compare 5 dental offices in Middle Island, NY. Each office page has contact details to help you plan your visit.

How can I compare Middle Island dental offices?

Use the Dental.me Score, Google reviews, location and type of care to narrow your choices. Follow an office's website link or call it to discuss treatment and payment.

How does Dental.me rank Middle Island dentists?

Organic results use Dental.me Score, an independent score built from star-rating strength, review-count confidence caps, exact review-count tie-breakers, and a limited verification lift. Profile completeness can help break close ties after the score. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.

Comparing Middle Island dentists

Rated Middle Island offices average 4.30 stars across 682 combined Google reviews, compared with 4.46 statewide. 2 local offices are rated 4.9 to 5.0, while 1 currently hold a Dental.me Score of 96 or higher.

Current score leaders: Alan Ellman - Harvey Lindenbaum DDS (Score 98, 4.9 stars, 679 reviews); Tamer Barsom (Score 84, 5.0 stars, 1 reviews); Total Dental Care of Middle Island P.C. (Score 60, 3.0 stars, 2 reviews). The most Google reviews are for Alan Ellman - Harvey Lindenbaum DDS, with 679 reviews at 4.9 stars.

The listed ZIP code has 5 dental offices: 11953 (5).

Because Middle Island has 5 listed offices, every local result fits in one comparison view:

For a wider search near Middle Island, compare Selden (4 miles, 16 offices), Rocky Point (5 miles, 7 offices), Shoreham (5 miles, 7 offices), Medford (5 miles, 16 offices), Miller Place (5 miles, 10 offices).

Read how Dental.me checks dentist details.

Own a practice in Middle Island?
Claim your free profile →

See an error? Request a correction · All NY dentists ↑