Dentists in Binghamton, NY: Local Guide

Quick answer: Binghamton, NY has 58 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 25 are rated on Google, averaging 3.96★ across 4,071 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Lalor Family Dental PLLC, Shakun Salomons & Bray, Dental P.C., Perna Dental. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.

Binghamton is the city where the average lies to you. Across the 58 dental practices Dental.me tracks in the Southern Tier hub, the 25 with enough Google reviews to grade average out to just 3.96 stars — the lowest headline rating of any comparable city in our current New York coverage. Read that number at face value and you would think Binghamton is a dental desert. It isn’t. That 3.96 is a statistical mirage, hiding a market split almost perfectly in two.

Here is the split that matters. Of those 25 graded practices, 8 sit at 4.8 stars or higher — highly rated, hundreds-of-reviews-deep offices. But 11 sit below 4.0, the largest low-rated cluster we see in any city this size. Only 3 practices land in the comfortable 4.5–4.79 middle, and 3 more in the 4.0–4.49 band. In most towns, ratings pile up in that safe middle. In Binghamton they collapse to the edges. You are not choosing from a bell curve here; you are choosing from a canyon — and which side of it you land on is entirely up to how carefully you pick.

What the 3.96 is really telling you

An average is only useful when the data clusters around it. Binghamton’s doesn’t. When roughly 44% of the town’s graded dentists fall under four stars, the mean gets dragged into no-man’s-land — a score that neither the excellent offices nor the struggling ones would recognize as their own. The practical takeaway is blunt: in a polarized market, generic advice (“just pick a highly-rated dentist near you”) is worth more here than almost anywhere, because the downside cases are real and numerous. You cannot coast on the city’s reputation. You have to choose the practice.

The good news is that the top of Binghamton’s market is deep and easy to verify. Only 20 of the 58 practices even maintain a website, and just 25 carry enough review history to grade — so the field of serious, established offices is smaller and clearer than the raw count of 58 suggests. That’s a feature, not a bug: it means the shortlist of proven names is short, and every one of them has a public track record you can read before you ever pick up the phone. Start that homework on the Binghamton dentist directory, where every practice below is checked against Google’s live rating data.

There is a second lesson buried in the numbers, and it’s about how much feedback sits behind a rating. Across all 25 graded offices, the average practice carries roughly 163 reviews — but that figure is wildly uneven, skewed by a handful of high-volume names at the top. A 5.0 built on a dozen reviews and a 4.9 built on hundreds are not the same signal, especially in a town where the low end is this crowded. When two Binghamton offices show a similar star score, let review depth break the tie: an average built on hundreds of ratings moves far less on chance than one resting on a thin sample. It’s the single most useful habit you can bring to a polarized market like this one.

The proven names — and the one that towers over them

If you want to skip straight to the deep end of the pool, these are the offices carrying both a high rating and enough reviews to trust it. One of them is not like the others.

Lalor Family Dental PLLC is, statistically, the center of gravity of dental care in Binghamton. Its 1,589 Google reviews at a 4.9 rating account for roughly 39% of every dental review written in this city. No single practice we track anywhere in the Southern Tier dominates its market’s review volume the way Lalor does here. When a general-dentistry office earns near-perfect marks across that many patients, it is not a fluke — it’s an operational standard held over years.

Depth, though, is not the same as being right for you, and Binghamton’s high end has real range beyond its giant:

• Courtney Gormley holds the city’s only perfect 5.0 among graded offices (97 reviews) — a smaller, spotless record for patients who prize a boutique feel.
• Shakun Salomons & Bray, Dental P.C. pairs a 4.9 rating with 317 reviews — an established group practice with breadth.
• Progressive Dental of Binghamton, PLLC (4.8, 316 reviews) is a proven mid-volume alternative if the top names are booked out.
• Perna Dental keeps a 4.9 across 188 reviews — consistent marks at a human scale.
• Oral Surgery Associates (4.6, 39 reviews) is the surgical name to know when a general dentist refers you out.

Where Binghamton’s specialty coverage runs thin

This is the other place the data earns its keep. Filter Binghamton by specialty and only two categories surface with real depth: dental implant providers (7 practices) and periodontists (6 practices). Notably absent from the local cluster are standalone orthodontic, pediatric, and cosmetic practices at the volume you’d find in a larger metro. That gap is exactly why Greater Binghamton behaves as one connected market — families routinely cross town lines for kids’ braces or a cosmetic consult. If your need is implants or gum health, you can stay in the city; for much else, plan to look at the ring of towns around it.

The concentration in implants and periodontics is not random, either. Both are the services an aging Southern Tier population needs most, and both reward the deep-experience, high-review offices that anchor Binghamton’s top tier — the same practices that show up when you filter for general dentistry. In other words, the city’s strengths overlap: the offices patients trust for a routine cleaning are frequently the same ones equipped for the surgical work that follows. That overlap is worth exploiting. Rather than starting your search over for each new need, build your care around one or two proven anchors and let them refer you out for the rest, whether that’s a specialist across town or a practice in Vestal or Johnson City.

A choosing method that fits a polarized town

Because Binghamton’s downside is genuinely present, treat the first appointment as a two-step filter rather than a coin flip. First, rule the field down to the proven side of the canyon — the eight offices at 4.8+ and the deep-review names above — and simply don’t shortlist anyone under four stars unless a trusted person vouches for them. Second, match to need: a giant like Lalor for full-family general care, Gormley for a boutique 5.0 experience, the implant or periodontal specialists for surgical work, and the nearby towns for the specialties Binghamton doesn’t stock. It is a five-minute process when you start from data instead of a search-ad. Curious how we grade every office and why review depth matters as much as the star number? Our ranking methodology lays out the exact signals, and the full Binghamton directory lets you filter the whole field yourself.

Looking just past the city line

Greater Binghamton is a tight cluster, and the best specialist for your situation may be a ten-minute drive away. Our directories for the surrounding communities carry the same Google rating data:

• Johnson City dentists
• Vestal dentists
• Endwell dentists
• Conklin dentists
• Kirkwood dentists
• Chenango Bridge dentists

Binghamton rewards the careful chooser more than most cities do. The excellent offices here are highly rated and easy to verify; the weak ones are numerous enough that a lazy pick carries real risk. Do the five minutes of homework, start from the proven side of the split, and the town’s low headline average stops being a warning and becomes your advantage. Begin with the Binghamton dentist directory.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.