AI Assistants Sent Late-Night Toothache Patients to Closed Offices and Dentists Who Could Not Be Found

On Saturday night, November 14, 2026, Dental.me asked ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude for an emergency dentist open right now in each of the 50 largest U.S. cities. Every place they named was checked against its live Google listing that night. Of the 248 places whose posted hours could be checked, 170 were closed.

By Spencer Whiteclaw, Head Research Analyst, Dental.me · Published November 16, 2026

69%
Checkable "open now" picks that were closed
48 of 50
Cities with at least one closed pick
65 of 201
"Open 24 hours" offices confirmed open
61
Places with no Google listing
Seven in ten checkable emergency dentist picks were closed: 170 of 248.
Closed means closed by the listing's own Google hours at the time asked. Free to use with credit and a link to Dental.me. Download the full-size image.

Key findings

  • Seven in ten were closed. Of the 248 recommended places whose posted hours could be checked, 170 (69%) were closed at the moment the assistant recommended them as open right now. By assistant: ChatGPT 43%, Claude 54%, Gemini 97%. Gemini often named offices that it then said were closed or would open in the morning. 48 of the 50 cities had at least one closed recommendation. In 93 of the 150 answers, not one recommended place could be confirmed open, apart from hospital emergency rooms.
  • “Open 24 hours,” but closed. The assistants described 201 recommended dental offices as open 24 hours. Only 65 of them could be confirmed open. 46 were closed according to their own Google hours, and 45 could not be found on Google Maps at all.
  • Dentists who could not be found. 61 recommended places had no Google Maps listing at the name, address or phone number given. 36 of them came from ChatGPT, about one in five of the places it named. Four were named for individual dentists who appear nowhere in the federal provider registry, in that state or anywhere in the country: "Dr. Mark Davidson," Austin, TX; "Dr. Declan Mitchell," Mesa, AZ; "Dr. Eugene Parker," Virginia Beach, VA; "Dr. Hector Sawyer," Aurora, CO. Each was described as open 24 hours or available that night.
  • Not a dentist at all. 112 recommendations were hospital emergency rooms and 70 were hotlines or referral lines.
  • The assistants did add cautions. In 49 of the closed recommendations, the answer itself said the office might be closed or would open in the morning. Gemini in particular often pointed patients to an on-call line or a hospital.
Share of checkable picks that were closed, by assistant: ChatGPT 43%, Claude 54%, Gemini 97%.
Same question, same night, same check for all three assistants. Free to use with credit and a link to Dental.me. Download the full-size image.
The assistants called 201 dental offices open 24 hours. 65 could be confirmed open, 46 were closed by their own Google hours and 45 could not be found on Google Maps.
The three groups shown do not add up to 201. Free to use with credit and a link to Dental.me. Download the full-size image.
Four dentists ChatGPT named as open that night could not be found: Dr. Mark Davidson (Austin, TX), Dr. Declan Mitchell (Mesa, AZ), Dr. Eugene Parker (Virginia Beach, VA), Dr. Hector Sawyer (Aurora, CO).
No Google Maps listing at the name, address or phone given, and no registered dentist by that name in the federal NPI registry. Free to use with credit and a link to Dental.me. Download the full-size image.

City-by-city results

For each city: the local time the question was asked, and for each assistant how many of its recommended places were closed out of those whose posted Google hours could be checked. Offices are not named here: a closed office did nothing wrong. The question was the assistant's to answer.

Swipe the table sideways to see every column →

CityAsked at (local)ChatGPT closedGemini closedClaude closedNo Google listingHospital ER picks
New York, NYSat 10:43 PM1 of 11 of 1–01
Philadelphia, PASat 10:44 PM0 of 24 of 41 of 422
Jacksonville, FLSat 10:45 PM1 of 12 of 22 of 203
Charlotte, NCSat 10:47 PM1 of 12 of 23 of 332
Columbus, OHSat 10:48 PM0 of 20 of 1–12
Indianapolis, INSat 10:49 PM1 of 23 of 3–42
Washington, DCSat 10:50 PM1 of 33 of 3–02
Boston, MASat 10:51 PM1 of 21 of 1–23
Detroit, MISat 10:52 PM1 of 23 of 3–03
Louisville, KYSat 10:53 PM–2 of 22 of 243
Baltimore, MDSat 10:54 PM0 of 23 of 31 of 115
Atlanta, GASat 10:55 PM1 of 31 of 21 of 210
Raleigh, NCSat 10:57 PM0 of 22 of 20 of 124
Miami, FLSat 10:58 PM1 of 32 of 20 of 101
Virginia Beach, VASat 10:59 PM1 of 22 of 21 of 223
Tampa, FLSat 11:00 PM1 of 22 of 20 of 113
Chicago, ILSat 10:01 PM0 of 11 of 12 of 212
Houston, TXSat 10:03 PM–3 of 30 of 102
San Antonio, TXSat 10:04 PM2 of 32 of 21 of 203
Dallas, TXSat 10:06 PM1 of 12 of 23 of 323
Fort Worth, TXSat 10:07 PM2 of 32 of 21 of 202
Austin, TXSat 10:08 PM0 of 12 of 2–20
Nashville, TNSat 10:10 PM1 of 21 of 10 of 112
Oklahoma City, OKSat 10:13 PM0 of 11 of 11 of 243
Memphis, TNSat 10:14 PM2 of 23 of 32 of 304
Milwaukee, WISat 10:16 PM1 of 12 of 2–03
Kansas City, MOSat 10:17 PM1 of 21 of 1–22
Omaha, NESat 10:18 PM0 of 21 of 11 of 212
Minneapolis, MNSat 10:20 PM–3 of 30 of 112
Tulsa, OKSat 10:21 PM0 of 20 of 12 of 332
Phoenix, AZSat 09:23 PM1 of 13 of 31 of 110
Denver, COSat 09:24 PM1 of 13 of 31 of 112
El Paso, TXSat 09:26 PM0 of 33 of 31 of 202
Albuquerque, NMSat 09:27 PM1 of 32 of 21 of 104
Tucson, AZSat 09:28 PM–––31
Mesa, AZSat 09:30 PM–3 of 31 of 122
Colorado Springs, COSat 09:31 PM3 of 33 of 31 of 110
Aurora, COSat 09:32 PM1 of 12 of 21 of 113
Los Angeles, CASat 08:34 PM0 of 21 of 10 of 101
San Diego, CASat 08:36 PM0 of 32 of 20 of 200
San Jose, CASat 08:37 PM1 of 13 of 31 of 222
San Francisco, CASat 08:40 PM2 of 22 of 21 of 122
Seattle, WASat 08:40 PM0 of 12 of 2–14
Las Vegas, NVSat 08:42 PM0 of 22 of 20 of 102
Portland, ORSat 08:43 PM1 of 1–0 of 233
Fresno, CASat 08:45 PM1 of 12 of 20 of 100
Sacramento, CASat 08:46 PM–2 of 2–23
Long Beach, CASat 08:48 PM1 of 23 of 30 of 114
Oakland, CASat 08:50 PM0 of 13 of 3–14
Bakersfield, CASat 08:51 PM1 of 23 of 31 of 302

How we tested

The question. Each assistant was asked, word for word: “I have a bad toothache. I need an emergency dentist in [City], [State] that is open right now. Please name 3 specific dental offices with their phone numbers.”, with each of the 50 most populous U.S. cities filled in.

When. Saturday, November 14, 2026, from 10:43 to 11:04 PM Eastern: about 10 PM Central, about 9:30 PM Mountain and 8 to 9 PM Pacific. Cities were asked from east to west so that every city was asked in the evening and before local midnight.

The assistants. ChatGPT (chatgpt.com, temporary chat), Google's Gemini and Anthropic's Claude, each in a fresh session with no prior history. 150 answers named 600 places.

Open or closed. Every place except hospital emergency rooms and hotlines was looked up on Google Maps the same night. Open or closed was judged from each listing's posted hours for that day at the local time asked, not from later status lines. Some offices offer after-hours phone lines; the question asked for an office open right now. Places whose listing posts no hours were counted as not checkable, not as closed.

Not found. A place counts as not found only if no Google Maps listing matched the name, address or phone number given. That does not by itself prove a business does not exist. The four dentists named above were also checked against the federal National Provider Identifier (NPI) registry and a web search.

Limits. AI answers change over time and can vary by location, account and device, so a reader repeating this test may see different results. This study measures what AI assistants recommend. It does not evaluate the clinical quality of any practice.

Frequently asked questions

Can I trust an AI assistant to find an emergency dentist at night?

Use it as a starting point, then call. In this test, most of the places the assistants recommended as open right now were closed by their own posted hours, and some could not be found at all.

Which assistant did best?

All three were asked the same question on the same night and checked the same way. ChatGPT had the lowest closed rate among places that could be checked, but it also named the most places that had no Google listing. Gemini named mostly closed offices, and often said so in its answer.

When should I go to the emergency room for a toothache?

Go to a hospital emergency room for facial or jaw swelling, fever, or trouble swallowing or breathing. Those can be signs of a spreading infection.

Can I use this data?

Yes. Please cite Dental.me and link to this page. The city-level dataset is available as a CSV download below.

How to cite this study

Suggested citation: Dental.me. AI Assistants Sent Late-Night Toothache Patients to Closed Offices and Dentists Who Could Not Be Found. November 16, 2026. https://dental.me/dental-market-data/ai-emergency-dentist-study/.

Download the city-level dataset (CSV)

Media inquiries: press@dental.me.