◆ Among the top 36% of Commack dentists

Toby Mathews

★★★★4.7 · 599 Google reviews Dentist in Commack, NY
★ 4.7 rating ✓ 500+ reviews ✓ Dental.me Profile

Last updated Aug 31, 2026 · Dental.me Score is independent and can’t be bought.

Quick answer: Toby Mathews in Commack

Toby Mathews has 4.7-star rating across 599 Google reviews, Dental.me Score 94 out of 100, address in Commack, NY, phone number, website, 1 dentist named, 8 business categories, and 5 days with hours on Dental.me. Compare contact details, map context, provider names, business categories, reviews, Dental.me Score, hours, and nearby dental options.

Top 36% of 44
Commack dentists by Dental.me Score
4.7 vs 4.7
its rating vs the Commack average
Top 7%
review volume — 599 beats 93% of Commack practices

About Toby Mathews

Toby Mathews is located at 6222 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725. Its Dental.me profile includes phone, website, dentist names, dental categories, Google rating and review data, business hours, and Google Maps details.

To contact the office, call (631) 499-9393, visit thesmilist.com, and open its Google Maps profile.

Dentists at this practice: Toby Mathews, DDS.

Dental categories connected to this profile: General Dentistry, Cosmetic Dentists, Orthodontists, Periodontists, Teeth Whitening, Emergency Dentists, Dental Implants, and Dentist.

General DentistryCosmetic DentistsOrthodontistsPeriodontistsTeeth WhiteningEmergency DentistsDental ImplantsDentist

Reviews and ratings for Toby Mathews

Google business data shows Toby Mathews with a 4.7-star rating across 599 reviews.

Toby Mathews has a Dental.me Score of 94, calculated from star-rating strength, review-count confidence, exact review-count tie-breakers, and limited verification signals.

Within Commack, this profile ranks #16 out of 44 scored dental profiles on Dental.me.

View Google reviews for Toby Mathews →

What Dental.me knows about this practice

Location
6222 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
Contact paths
phone, website, and Google Maps
Google review signal
4.7 stars from 599 reviews
Dental.me Score
94/100 score
Dentists connected
Toby Mathews, DDS
Category signals
General Dentistry, Cosmetic Dentists, Orthodontists, Periodontists, Teeth Whitening, Emergency Dentists, Dental Implants, and Dentist
Business hours
5 days with published hours

How it compares in Commack

RankDentistRatingReviewsScore
#14Maryanne Carletto4.99095
#15Robert I. Halle, DMD, PC4.94594
#16Toby MathewsYou’re viewing4.759994
#17Commack Pediatric Dentistry, P.C.4.714394
#18Steven Feigelson4.73192
For this practice’s team: This practice scores 94. Verify it to raise its Dental.me Score to 97. Verify now →

Practice details

Address
6222 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
Phone
(631) 499-9393
Dentists
Toby Mathews, DDS
Google profile
View on Maps · 599 reviews

Compare and contact Toby Mathews

Compare Toby Mathews using address, phone, website, 4.7-star Google rating, 599 Google reviews, Dental.me Score 94, 1 named dentist, 8 dental categories, and 5 days with published hours.

Open the Commack dentist directory to compare other local profiles, or browse the New York dental directory for a statewide view.

Frequently asked questions

How do I contact Toby Mathews?
Call Toby Mathews at (631) 499-9393. For more information, visit thesmilist.com.
Where is Toby Mathews located?
Toby Mathews is located at 6222 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725.
Which dentists are at this office?
Dentists at this office include Toby Mathews, DDS.
Does Toby Mathews have a website?
Yes. The website for Toby Mathews is thesmilist.com.
What rating does Google show for Toby Mathews?
Google business data shows Toby Mathews with a 4.7-star rating from 599 reviews.
What are Toby Mathews's business hours?
Business hours shown: Monday 9AM–8PM; Tuesday 8AM–8PM; Wednesday 9AM–7PM; Thursday 9AM–7PM; Friday 8AM–4PM; Saturday Closed; Sunday Closed.
What dental categories is Toby Mathews connected to?
Business categories connected to this practice include General Dentistry, Cosmetic Dentists, Orthodontists, Periodontists, Teeth Whitening, Emergency Dentists, Dental Implants, and Dentist.
Other dentists in Commack
This practice’s services in Commack
Dentists in nearby cities
Compare more dentists near Commack
Dental.me guides for Commack

How Dental.me verifies this data. We combine provider, location, business-profile, practice website, dentist-submitted, correction, and direct office-confirmation data. Profiles show a last-updated date, and rankings are independent of paid placement. Verification methodology · How we rank

Profile data includes practice, provider, location, and business-profile information organized by Dental.me. Last updated August 31, 2026.