Central Islip, NY Dentists
Dental.me currently ranks 6 dental offices in Central Islip, NY (Suffolk County). 4 have Google rating data across 114 reviews, averaging 4.00 stars. Current score leaders include Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMD and Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDS. Featured placements remain separate from organic rank.
Last updated Aug 31, 2026 · How we rank →
How we rank · independent Dental.me Score · Featured is separate and cannot buy rank.
Featured dentists in Central Islip
Three featured practices in Central Islip.
Featured placements are labeled and shown separately. They do not affect the Dental.me Score or the organic ranking below.
Dentists in Central Islip, NY — ranked
Showing 1–6 of 6
The Central Islip dental market, by the numbers
A live read on how Central Islip’s 6 offices compare — unique to this city, drawn from the same data behind every practice profile.
Dental.me Score distribution
How Central Islip’s rated offices spread across score tiers.
Rating vs. New York
Average Google rating across rated Central Islip offices.
Central Islip dental leaders
Two independent cuts of the same data — highest scored, and most reviewed.
Highest Dental.me Score
Top of the independent, non-paid ranking.
- Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMDScore 84 · 5.0 ★ · 2 reviews
- Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDSScore 84 · 5.0 ★ · 1 reviews
- Long Island Select Healthcare Inc.Score 70 · 3.5 ★ · 76 reviews
- Kirshenbaum Peruso Kautman LLPScore 50 · 2.5 ★ · 35 reviews
Most reviewed offices
Largest Google review counts in Central Islip.
- Long Island Select Healthcare Inc.76 reviews · 3.5 ★
- Kirshenbaum Peruso Kautman LLP35 reviews · 2.5 ★
- Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMD2 reviews · 5.0 ★
- Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDS1 reviews · 5.0 ★
Dental.me guides for Central Islip
Use these Dental.me guides and comparison hubs with the Central Islip directory to compare dentists, specialties, Dental.me Score, review signals, costs, insurance questions, and questions to ask before booking.
Guide links connect this city directory to the broader New York and national Dental.me research library. Organic rankings use Dental.me Score; Featured placements stay separate from the ranked list.
Nearby cities
Nearby cities with dentists, by distance from Central Islip.
Use the Central Islip directory with the broader New York directory hub. Dental.me connects city pages, practice profiles, supported specialty hubs, market data, ranking methodology, claim tools, and correction workflows with crawlable links.
High-coverage New York city directories
Statewide specialty hubs
Specialty categories help patients compare relevant offices, while each practice profile and its website, map, and phone details complete the path for appointments, insurance, and payment questions.
Common questions about dentists in Central Islip
Who are the highest-rated dentists in Central Islip, NY?
By Dental.me Score, the top-rated Central Islip dentists are Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMD (Dental.me Score 84, 5.0 stars, 2 reviews); Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDS (Dental.me Score 84, 5.0 stars, 1 reviews); Long Island Select Healthcare Inc. (Dental.me Score 70, 3.5 stars, 76 reviews). Across the city, 2 offices are rated 4.9 to 5.0. The ranked list above updates as new review data comes in.
Are dentists in Central Islip, NY good?
Central Islip's rated dental offices average 4.00 stars on Google - compared with a 4.46 New York average, and 2 are rated 4.9 to 5.0. The Dental.me Score ranks them by star-rating strength and review volume so you can compare the strongest offices first.
What dental categories are common in Central Islip, NY?
Common Dental.me categories connected to Central Islip profiles include General Dentistry, Endodontists, Pediatric Dentists, Periodontists. Category data helps organize local options and gives patients a faster way to compare offices by the type of care they are researching.
How many dentists are in Central Islip, NY?
Dental.me organizes 6 dental practice profiles in Central Islip, NY. 1 has at least one dentist named in Dental.me data. Each profile can be claimed or corrected to add detail.
How many Central Islip dentists have Google/Maps data, websites, or ratings?
In Central Islip, 4 practices have Google/Maps enrichment, 1 list a website, and 4 show a star rating. Dental.me uses those signals to make local comparison faster and more useful.
How does Dental.me rank Central Islip dentists?
Organic results use Dental.me Score, an independent score built from star-rating strength, review-count confidence caps, exact review-count tie-breakers, and a limited verification lift. Profile completeness can help break close ties after the score. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.
What the Central Islip dental data shows
Of the 6 Central Islip offices in this directory, 4 (67%) have Google rating data, 1 (17%) publish a website, 2 (33%) include hours, and 1 (17%) connect at least one dentist name. Google/Maps enrichment currently covers 4 profiles (67%).
Rated Central Islip offices average 4.00 stars across 114 combined Google reviews, compared with 4.46 statewide. 2 local offices are rated 4.9 to 5.0, while 0 currently hold a Dental.me Score of 96 or higher.
Current score leaders: Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMD (Score 84, 5.0 stars, 2 reviews); Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDS (Score 84, 5.0 stars, 1 reviews); Long Island Select Healthcare Inc. (Score 70, 3.5 stars, 76 reviews). The city’s largest review sample belongs to Long Island Select Healthcare Inc., with 76 Google reviews at 3.5 stars.
The three ZIP codes with the most listed offices account for 6 practices (100% of the city directory): 11722 (6).
Because Central Islip has 6 listed offices, every local result fits in one comparison view:
- Dr. Sheldon E. Winik, DMD at 159 Carleton Ave — 5.0 stars across 2 Google reviews — (631) 439-4300.
- Dr. Alan M. Winik, DDS at 159 Carleton Ave — 5.0 stars across 1 Google reviews — (631) 439-4300.
- Long Island Select Healthcare Inc. at 159 Carleton Ave — 3.5 stars across 76 Google reviews — (631) 650-2510.
- Kirshenbaum Peruso Kautman LLP at 109 Carleton Ave — 2.5 stars across 35 Google reviews — (631) 348-2500.
- Carleton Avenue Dental PC at 70 Carleton Avenue — (631) 582-6335.
- Hope Arnoldt at 109 Carleton Ave Carleton Avenue Family Dental — (631) 348-2500.
For a wider search near Central Islip, compare Brentwood (2 miles, 23 offices), Islandia (2 miles, 6 offices), Islip Terrace (2 miles, 4 offices), Hauppauge (3 miles, 28 offices), Islip (3 miles, 24 offices).
Data snapshot: Aug 31, 2026. Counts come from Dental.me’s organized provider, practice, location, website, and Google/Maps business-profile data. See our verification methodology.