Dentists in Youngstown, OH: Local Guide

Quick answer: Youngstown, OH has 85 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 37 are rated on Google, averaging 4.11★ across 2,605 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: David Waldman, Daniel G. Very, DMD Mds Inc, Orlosky Dental. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.

Most city dental markets we map look like a bell curve: a fat middle of solid four-star practices, a handful of standouts, a few laggards. Youngstown does not. Of the 85 dental practices we track across the city, only 37 have collected enough Google reviews to carry a reliable rating at all — and among those 37, the scores split into two camps that barely touch. Twelve practices sit at 4.8 stars or higher. Another twelve sit below 4.0. That is not a curve; it is a barbell. The city-wide average lands at just 4.11, the lowest of any market in this data wave.

What that means for you, as someone looking for a dentist here, is simple and a little unusual: the average practice is not a safe bet. In a town where nearly a third of rated offices score under four stars, picking blind is a real gamble. But the good news buried in the same numbers is that the top of this market is highly rated — a few Youngstown offices have earned hundreds of near-perfect reviews. The whole job is telling the two groups apart. This guide shows you how, using nothing but the real data behind the Youngstown dentist directory.

The shape of the market, in one picture

Two numbers on that chart deserve a second look. First, only 22 of 85 practices maintain a working website. In most cities we track that figure is well over half. Here it is barely a quarter, which tells you a lot of Youngstown dentistry is still run the old way — phone, front desk, word of mouth. That is not automatically bad, but it does mean the internet will tell you less than usual, so the ratings that do exist carry more weight. Second, those 37 rated offices hold only 2,605 reviews between them — an average of about 70 apiece. A practice with 12 reviews and a practice with 700 are not equally proven, and in a thin market that gap matters enormously.

It is worth sitting with that review figure for a moment, because it reframes the whole search. In a mid-size, review-rich suburb, a single well-established office can carry a thousand reviews on its own. Youngstown’s entire rated market — all 37 practices combined — holds only about 2,605. That scarcity cuts two ways. On one hand, a handful of practices have quietly accumulated the lion’s share of that feedback, which makes them stand out clearly once you know to look. On the other, dozens of offices have so little public history that the internet simply cannot tell you whether they are good. When the data runs out, the phone call and the in-person consultation stop being optional courtesies and become your primary research tools.

Why the barbell happens — and what to do about it

When you plot every rated Youngstown practice by its star band, the split is impossible to miss:

A market splits like this when the good operators pull far ahead and the weak ones never improve — there is no crowded middle pulling everyone toward the mean. For you the practical rule is aim for the top band and don’t settle for “fine.” Because the excellent practices here are truly excellent, you rarely have to compromise. The clearest example is David Waldman, who has earned a 4.9 rating across 737 reviews — more than a quarter of every review in the entire city. When one office holds that much Google review data at that score, the signal is about as strong as local data gets.

Behind Waldman, the proven tier is short but real. Daniel G. Very, DMD carries a 4.9 across 305 reviews, and Orlosky Dental holds a perfect 5.0 over 113 reviews — a smaller sample, but a spotless one. From there the review counts drop off quickly: Michael Deperro (4.7, 62 reviews), John F. Geletka DDS (4.7, 43 reviews), and Dante M. DeChellis, DDS (a perfect 5.0, but on just 23 reviews). Notice how fast the evidence thins — that fall-off is the whole story of this market. Weigh the score and the number of reviews behind it; a 4.7 on 62 reviews is a firmer bet than a 5.0 on a dozen.

The gap between these top names and the bottom band is what makes Youngstown a “do your homework” market rather than a “walk into the nearest office” one. Consider the spread: the best-reviewed practice in the city sits at 4.9 stars on hundreds of reviews, while twelve rated offices — nearly a third of everything with a score — land under 4.0. There is almost no comfortable middle to fall back on if you pick without checking. In a bell-curve city the downside of a random choice is usually a merely average visit. Here, the downside is materially worse, and the upside of choosing well is materially better. That asymmetry is the single most important thing to understand about dental care in Youngstown, and it should shape every decision that follows.

The specialty gap: plan to travel

Here is where Youngstown differs most sharply from the suburban markets nearby. In our data, the only specialty with meaningful listed depth inside the city is dental implants — and even that is thin at five practices. Orthodontics, pediatric dentistry, periodontics, endodontics, oral surgery: for general-dentistry needs the city is covered, but for specialist care you should expect to look beyond the city line.

This is not a warning — it is a routing tip. Youngstown sits inside a tight cluster of suburbs, and specialist depth improves as soon as you cross into them. If you need braces, a root canal, or an implant consultation and your Youngstown general dentist refers out, the nearby options are close: Boardman and Canfield to the south, Austintown to the west, and Struthers, Campbell, and Leetonia ringing the metro. For implants specifically, you can start with the five in-city options on the Youngstown implant page before widening the search.

A vetting routine that fits a thin market

Because so much of Youngstown’s market is unrated or offline, the usual “just check the reviews” advice only gets you halfway. Here is the order of operations that actually protects you here:

Step four matters everywhere, but it matters more in a market where quality varies this widely: a low headline price from a low-rated office is not a bargain. Before you compare quotes, it helps to know what routine work should actually cost — our national dental cost guide gives you the benchmarks, and our ranking methodology explains exactly how the star bands above are calculated so you can judge them for yourself.

The short version

Youngstown is not a hard city to find great dental care in — it is a hard city to find great care in by accident. The top tier is small, deep, and excellent; the bottom tier is unusually large; and the middle you would normally lean on barely exists. Skip the average, aim straight for the proven names, expect to travel for specialists, and confirm price before you sit in the chair. Start your search from the full, continuously updated Youngstown dentist directory, where every practice above is ranked by the same review data used throughout this guide.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.