Finding a dentist in Winter Garden starts with narrowing 35 listed practices to the 21 that carry a star rating on file, which average 4.53 stars. Weigh each rating against the reviews behind it, confirm the specialty you need, and use the table below to shortlist three to call.
Dental.me lists 35 practices in Winter Garden. 21 of them have a Google rating and 14 do not: 2 show zero reviews and 12 have no review count on file. Together the 21 rated offices hold 5,076 Google reviews. Phone numbers are on file for all 35, giving 32 distinct numbers, and posted weekly hours are stored for 21. Tailyn Medina Suarez (4.8 on 227) shares its phone with an unrated HAMLIN FAMILY DENTISTRY, INC record, and Renee Fajardin (4.4 on 597) shares one with unrated Callista Schulenburg and Gerald Bennett records. Check the profile before you treat two names as two offices. This guide turns those numbers into a shortlist you can act on.
What the Winter Garden numbers actually tell you
The headline figure is the 4.53-star average across the 21 rated practices. It is an unweighted mean, so a 5.0 on one review counts as much as a 5.0 on 639. Weighted by review count, the 21 rated practices average 4.66. The shape underneath is top-heavy: of the 21 rated offices, 12 sit in the 4.8-and-above band, 3 land between 4.5 and 4.79, 4 fall between 4.0 and 4.49, and 2 sit below 4.0. The 12 offices at 4.8 or higher average 4.91, and three of those ratings rest on fewer than 50 reviews (12, 7 and 1). So your real decision is rarely “good versus bad” — it is choosing among a dozen highly rated offices based on specialty, location, and how much review evidence stands behind each rating.
The six highest Dental.me Scores in Winter Garden
The table below lists the six Winter Garden offices that pair a rating of 4.8 or higher with more than 200 reviews, shown by rating and then by review count. The same six hold the six highest Dental.me Scores, and Hamlin Modern Dentistry, LLC and Maryana Zaverukha share the #3 Score. Advn Dental Partners PA leads at 5.0 on 639 reviews, the largest review count of any rated practice in the city (13% of the 5,076 total). Five other offices also hold a 5.0, on 126, 89, 12, 7 and 1 reviews, so a 5.0 on its own says little about how much feedback stands behind it.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advn Dental Partners PA | 5.0 | 639 | View profile |
| Brian Ramski | 4.9 | 349 | View profile |
| Hamlin Modern Dentistry, LLC | 4.8 | 478 | View profile |
| Maryana Zaverukha | 4.8 | 455 | View profile |
| Thomas Holehouse | 4.8 | 363 | View profile |
| Tailyn Medina Suarez | 4.8 | 227 | View profile |
Why review volume, not just the star, should guide your pick
A 4.8 on 478 reviews, like Hamlin Modern Dentistry, is an average across hundreds of separate reviews; a 4.8 on a dozen is not. All six offices above pair a rating of 4.8 or better with more than 200 reviews, and five of them clear 340. Together they hold 2,511 of the city's 5,076 reviews (49%). The table is not the six largest records: Comfortable Care Dental Health Professionals, P.A. (4.7 on 624, 10th on the Score), Renee Fajardin (4.4 on 597, 15th) and Timothy Davidson (3.9 on 524, 20th) hold the second-, third- and fourth-largest counts. Below the table, one more office holds a 4.8 on 157 reviews, and three of the city's 5.0 ratings rest on 12 or fewer.
How website coverage affects your search
Of the 35 practices Dental.me tracks in Winter Garden, 18 have a website URL on file — just over half. That gap is worth planning around. Where a website URL is on file, you can look at the practice’s own site before you pick up the phone. For the 17 practices with no website URL on file, the profile rating and review count are your primary read, and a direct call is the natural next step to confirm hours and availability. Neither group is inherently better; the difference simply changes how much homework you can do online before you call. Dental.me does not record why any office lacks a site, so do not read the absence of a site as a mark against a strong score. All 14 unrated offices are among the 17 with no URL on file.
What the bottom of the distribution means for you
Only 6 of the 21 rated practices fall below 4.5. Four sit between 4.0 and 4.49: Renee Fajardin (4.4 on 597), a second Comfortable Care Dental Health Professionals, P.A. listing (4.3 on 65), Mid-Florida Endodontics – Winter Garden (4.3 on 58) and Nadia Fleetwood (4.3 on 9). Two sit below 4.0: Timothy Davidson (3.9 on 524) and Andrew C Gooch DMD PLLC (1.0 on 2 reviews). A rating on hundreds of reviews and a rating on two are not the same evidence, so read the review count beside the star before you rule an office in or out. Dental.me holds no review dates, so it cannot tell you how recent a rating is.
Matching a Winter Garden dentist to what you need
General cleanings are only part of the picture. Dental.me sorts Winter Garden offices into 12 service lists, and all 12 hold at least one practice: nine list dental implants, nine cosmetic dentistry and nine teeth whitening. Eight list pediatric dentistry, and seven list orthodontics and seven Invisalign; if you hope to keep children's and adults' care in one office, ask which work each office does itself. Five list periodontal (gum) care, four endodontics, four oral surgery, three emergency care, and one each dentures and prosthodontics. Timothy Davidson is on 10 of the 12 lists, more than any other Winter Garden office. A list entry reflects the services a practice lists, not a specialist credential.
If you already know the treatment you are after, start from the specialty view rather than the full directory. Winter Garden’s dental implant providers, cosmetic dentistry offices and teeth whitening options pages each list nine offices. Filtering first means every office you compare lists the work you need; the ratings still cover the whole practice, not one service.
A practical order of operations
Put it together in order. Start with the ranked table and note two or three offices whose ratings and review depth both look strong. Cross-check each office’s address on its profile against where you live or work. Confirm the specialty you need against the specialty chart above. For any office with a website URL on file, skim it for insurance and new-patient details; for those without one, keep the number handy and call to confirm hours, availability, and whether they are taking new patients. The full Winter Garden directory lets you see every one of the 35 practices, not just the top six, when you want the complete picture.
If you are near the city line
Several neighbouring cities have their own Dental.me directories with the same rating and review data: Ocoee lists 28 practices (20 rated), Windermere 21 (9 rated), Clermont 63 (37 rated), Oakland 3 (1 rated) and Groveland 2 (1 rated). An office there can be compared with a Winter Garden one on equal terms. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.
Questions worth asking on the first call
Because 17 Winter Garden practices have no website URL on file, a short call often does more than an hour of browsing. Ask whether the office takes new patients. Dental.me does not record which insurance an office accepts. Confirm which insurance networks it is in and whether it offers a membership plan if you pay out of pocket. If you need a specific treatment, such as an implant consult, Invisalign or a pediatric visit, ask whether it is done in-house or referred elsewhere, since the service lists above reflect listed categories, not which offices do the work themselves. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.
How the Dental.me Score is built
The star ratings and review counts on this page are the Google figures held on each listing. The table above is shown by rating and then by review count, and the same six hold the six highest Dental.me Scores. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing, so a 5.0 on 639 reviews sits 1st and a 5.0 on one review sits 19th. Featured cards on the city hub mark a placement, not a Score result. The Winter Garden city directory runs over three pages, and its first cards are marked Featured and sit outside Score order. When this guide was checked they were Timothy Davidson (3.9 on 524; 20th of the 21 rated by Score), Lissette Bernal (5.0 on 1; 19th), Mid-Florida Endodontics – Winter Garden (4.3 on 58; tied 16th) and the second Comfortable Care Dental Health Professionals, P.A. listing (4.3 on 65; tied 16th).
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are there in Winter Garden, FL?
Dental.me tracks 35 dental practices in Winter Garden. Of those, 21 carry a star rating, and together they average 4.53 stars (an unweighted mean); 12 of the 21 sit at 4.8 or higher.
Which Winter Garden dental practice has the highest rating?
Six practices hold a 5.0. Advn Dental Partners PA has by far the most reviews behind its rating (639); the other five rest on 126, 89, 12, 7 and 1.
Which Winter Garden office has the most reviews?
Advn Dental Partners PA, with 639 reviews at a 5.0 rating, about 13% of the 5,076 reviews across Winter Garden's rated practices. The next three are Comfortable Care Dental Health Professionals, P.A. (624 at 4.7), Renee Fajardin (597 at 4.4) and Timothy Davidson (524 at 3.9).
Do Winter Garden dentists offer implants, Invisalign, and cosmetic work?
Yes. Nine practices list dental implants, nine list cosmetic dentistry, and nine list teeth whitening, while seven list Invisalign and seven list orthodontics. Eight list pediatric dentistry and five list periodontal care.
How many Winter Garden practices have a website?
Of the 35 tracked practices, 18 have a website URL on file — just over half. For the other 17 with no website URL on file, the rating, review count, and a direct call are your best way to check details.
Can a Winter Garden dentist pay for a higher Dental.me Score?
No. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. Featured cards on the city hub mark a placement, not a Score result.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.