Dentists in Williston Park, NY: Local Guide

Finding a good dentist in Williston Park, New York, starts with the numbers: the village has 21 dental practices, 17 of them carrying a published rating that averages 4.34 out of five. Ten of those rated offices sit at 4.8 or higher, so start your shortlist there and compare review counts before you call.

How Williston Park’s dental market breaks down

Williston Park is a compact incorporated village in Nassau County, tucked between Mineola, Albertson, and East Williston along the Hillside Avenue corridor of Long Island. For a village that spans well under a square mile, 21 dental practices is a dense count, and that density is what makes a structured shortlist worth the ten minutes it takes to build one. Of those 21 offices, 17 have accumulated enough feedback to carry a published star rating on Dental.me; the remaining four are listed but have not yet gathered a rating we can display, which does not mean they are new or lesser, only that the public record on them is still thin.

The 4.34 average across the rated 17 is a useful anchor, but averages flatten the picture. A single office rated 3.2 and a single office rated 5.0 average to a number neither one deserves. That is why the real work is reading the distribution: how many offices clear the high bar, how many sit in the safe middle, and how many trail. The four charts below turn Williston Park’s raw figures into that shape so you can see where the strong offices cluster and where the risk sits.

The highest-rated dentists in Williston Park

The table below lists Williston Park’s most-reviewed and highest-rated practices, sorted by star rating and then by review volume so the offices carrying both a top score and a deep body of feedback rise to the top. Every practice links to its full Dental.me profile, where you can read the underlying ratings and confirm the office details.

Three offices hold a perfect 5.0: Peter Ickowicz DDS, with 328 ratings, carries the deepest record of the three, while Joseph Locurto and David Klebanow pair the same perfect score with smaller bodies of 64 and 35 ratings. At 4.9, Gentle Touch Endodontics stands out for combining a near-perfect score with 249 ratings, and National Dental Williston Park holds the village’s single largest rating count at 400 while sitting at 4.7.

Reading the rating distribution

Here is how the 17 rated practices sort into rating bands. Ten of them sit at 4.8 or above, four land between 4.5 and 4.79, one falls in the 4.0-to-4.49 range, and two rate below 4.0. That top-heavy shape is the single most useful fact in this guide: in Williston Park, a strong shortlist is easy to assemble because well over half the rated offices clear the 4.8 mark.

The two offices below 4.0 are worth a closer look rather than an automatic pass. A low average on a small number of ratings can swing on a handful of entries, so open the profile, read how many ratings sit behind the score, and weigh it against convenience and the specific treatment you need. The distribution tells you where the safe majority is; it does not decide any single visit for you.

Website coverage across Williston Park practices

Of the 21 practices in Williston Park, 8 have a website URL on file, and eight do not. A website is convenient for checking services and location before you call, but its absence is a data point about the listing, not a verdict on the office: several well-rated practices in the village have no website URL on file. Use the presence of a site to save yourself a phone call, not to rank the dentist.

Review depth at the top practices

Williston Park’s rated practices have gathered 1,298 ratings in total, and that volume is concentrated at a few offices. Review depth matters because a 4.9 backed by 249 ratings is a steadier signal than a 5.0 backed by a dozen. The chart below shows the rating counts behind the six leading practices so you can weigh score against the weight of feedback supporting it.

Two patterns stand out. National Dental Williston Park and Peter Ickowicz DDS together account for well over half of the top six’s rating volume, so if breadth of feedback is your priority, those two lead. But Gentle Touch Endodontics shows that depth and a near-perfect score can travel together, which is exactly the combination worth prioritizing when the two align.

Specialty care in and around Williston Park

General cleanings are only part of the picture. Williston Park’s listings map cleanly onto the specialties most people search for, and the chart below shows how many practices are associated with each. Dental implants lead with nine associated practices, followed by cosmetic dentistry and teeth whitening at seven each, periodontics at six, and emergency dentistry at five.

If you are weighing a specific procedure, start from the specialty view rather than the full directory. You can browse the village’s dental implant providers in Williston Park, its cosmetic dentists, and its emergency dental options directly, each filtered to the offices associated with that care. That five practices are associated with emergency care is worth noting in advance: identify one before you need it, because the day of a broken tooth is the wrong time to start comparing.

If you look just beyond the village line

Williston Park’s borders are close enough that neighboring hamlets are a realistic part of your search, especially if the specialist you want has a shorter wait one town over. Mineola sits directly to the south and carries its own directory of practices; Albertson borders the village to the east; and New Hyde Park is a short drive west along the county line. Each links to a full directory you can compare on the same rating and review measures used here, so widening your radius does not mean lowering your standard.

How to turn this into a decision

Build your shortlist from the ten offices rated 4.8 or above, then narrow by the specialty you actually need using the category pages above and the full Williston Park dentist directory. When two offices look comparable, let review depth break the tie: a near-perfect score standing on a few hundred ratings is a more settled signal than the same score on a handful. Open each finalist’s profile to confirm the rating, the count behind it, and whether a website URL is on file before you call.

The Dental.me Score you see on each profile is earned, never sold. It weighs a practice’s rating, the volume of feedback behind it, and whether the office details have been confirmed, among other signals, so that a thin but glowing listing cannot outrank a deep and steady one on reputation alone. The only thing money changes on Dental.me is a Featured placement, which is labeled as such and never alters the Score or the ranking order you compare on. Use the numbers in this guide to walk into your first appointment already knowing where the office stands.

Frequently asked questions

How many dentists are there in Williston Park, NY?

Williston Park has 21 dental practices on Dental.me. Of those, 17 carry enough feedback to display a published rating, and together they hold 1,298 ratings. The remaining four are listed but do not yet have a displayable rating.

Which Williston Park dentist has the highest rating?

Three practices hold a perfect 5.0: Peter Ickowicz DDS (328 ratings), Joseph Locurto (64 ratings), and David Klebanow (35 ratings). Peter Ickowicz DDS carries the deepest body of feedback of the three.

What is the average dentist rating in Williston Park?

The 17 rated practices average 4.34 out of five. That average sits below the strongest offices because two practices rate under 4.0; ten of the 17 rated offices sit at 4.8 or higher.

Which Williston Park dentist has the most reviews?

National Dental Williston Park has the largest rating count in the village at 400, while holding a 4.7 rating. Peter Ickowicz DDS is next with 328 ratings at a perfect 5.0.

Can I find an emergency dentist in Williston Park?

Yes. Five practices in Williston Park are associated with emergency dental care. You can view them on the emergency dentists category page and identify one in advance so you are not comparing options during an urgent visit.

What specialties are available in Williston Park?

The most-covered specialties are dental implants (nine associated practices), cosmetic dentistry and teeth whitening (seven each), periodontics (six), and emergency dentistry (five). Each has its own filtered page in the Williston Park directory.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.