Quick answer: Reynoldsburg, OH has 47 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 24 are rated on Google, averaging 4.3★ across 5,061 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Buckeye Pediatric Dentistry and Sean E. Matheny, D.D.S., Inc. share first place, and Paul Loper is third. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.
| # | Practice | Google rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Buckeye Pediatric Dentistry | 4.9★ | 764 |
| 2 | Sean E. Matheny, D.D.S., Inc. | 4.9★ | 753 |
| 3 | Paul Loper | 5★ | 235 |
| 4 | Michael J. Smith, DDS, Inc. | 4.9★ | 281 |
| 5 | Denise Hering | 4.9★ | 218 |
The 4.3 average rating across Reynoldsburg’s 24 rated practices hides an uneven spread. Sixteen of the 24 rate 4.8 or better, three sit between 4.0 and 4.79, and five sit below 4.0. The top band is where most of the review volume is: its 16 offices hold 3,462 of the 5,061 Google reviews. The five below 4.0 hold 35 reviews between them, and four of the five rest on 10 or fewer.
That shape matters more than the headline number. A low rating on one or ten reviews is thin evidence, and so is a 5.0 on one or two, so read every rating with the count beside it. Start your search in the Reynoldsburg directory, where each profile shows both.
The largest review records are not all in the top band. BUCKEYE PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY (4.9 on 764) and SEAN E. MATHENY, D.D.S., INC. (4.9 on 753) hold the two largest; REYNOLDSBURG DENTAL CENTER (4.7 on 707) and East Broad Family Dentistry (4.7 on 603) hold the third- and fourth-largest. Stellar Dentistry of Reynoldsburg (4.8 on 385) and MICHAEL J. SMITH, DDS, INC. (4.9 on 281) complete the six, and the six largest records hold 3,493 of the 5,061 reviews (69 percent). Dental.me holds the ratings, not the reasons behind them, and a review count is not a measure of clinical quality.
Reading the rating bands before you book
Here is the distribution. Of the 24 Reynoldsburg practices with a Google rating, 16 sit at 4.8 or above, two between 4.5 and 4.79, one between 4.0 and 4.49 and five below 4.0. Three of the 16 top-band ratings are 5.0s on four or fewer reviews (4, 2 and 1).
Practically, the usual advice, to pick a well-reviewed office that suits you, works in Reynoldsburg: 13 rated offices have 100 or more reviews, and 10 of them rate 4.8 or higher. The 23 unrated offices have no Google reviews at all, so they are unmeasured, not judged.
The most-reviewed offices at 4.9 and up
These are the six 4.9-and-up offices with the most Google reviews. By Dental.me Score, Buckeye Pediatric Dentistry and Sean E. Matheny share first place, Paul Loper is third and Michael J. Smith fourth, and Denise Hering, East Columbus Family Dental Care and Nancy Montgomery (4.9 on 185) share fifth. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. It is never sold. Paid placements are clearly labeled as Featured and never change the organic order.
- Buckeye Pediatric Dentistry — 4.9 across 764 reviews, the largest review record in town. It is on the pediatric list, which matters if the search that brought you here is about your kids.
- Sean E. Matheny, D.D.S., Inc. — 4.9 across 753 reviews, 11 fewer than Buckeye.
- Michael J. Smith, DDS, Inc. — 4.9 across 281 reviews.
- Denise Hering — 4.9 across 218 reviews.
- Paul Loper — a perfect 5.0 across 235 reviews, the highest rating among the heavily reviewed offices.
- East Columbus Family Dental Care LLC — 4.9 across 199 reviews.
Notice the shape of that list: the two largest records, one of them on the pediatric list, then four offices with 199 to 281 reviews each. Paul Loper’s 5.0 on 235 reviews has the most reviews behind any of the city’s five 5.0 ratings; the next is Steven Stamas (5.0 on 80), and the other three rest on four or fewer. You can compare every rated office side by side on the Reynoldsburg practice hub.
Review count deserves a word of its own, because it is the check not to skip. A 5.0 on one review and a 4.9 on 764 carry very different certainty. Buckeye Pediatric Dentistry and Sean E. Matheny hold 1,517 reviews between them, and every office on the list above has more than 150. When you are comparing two offices you like, the one with several hundred reviews behind a high rating has the steadier rating, and the newest reviews on Google can show whether anyone mentions the treatment you need.
What the service lists show in Reynoldsburg
Eleven of Dental.me’s twelve service lists hold at least one Reynoldsburg practice. The cosmetic and teeth-whitening lists are the longest at 12 each, and they are the same 12 offices. The emergency and implant lists hold nine each. Two of the nine on the emergency list rate below 4.0 (2.8 on 17 reviews and 2.6 on 10), so read the rating and count there too. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.
If you know what you need, go straight to the list for it: cosmetic dentists, teeth whitening, emergency dentists, dental implants, pediatric dentists, periodontists, endodontists, orthodontists, Invisalign providers, dentures and prosthodontists. The orthodontist and Invisalign lists hold the same five offices. The dentures list holds two offices, the prosthodontist list one, and the oral-surgeon list is empty, so for those, check the nearby places below. Paul Loper and Michael J. Smith, the third and fourth Dental.me Scores, are on none, so check their profiles and call; so is East Broad Family Dentistry (4.7 on 603). A place on a list shows what an office lists, not how often it does that work, so ask whether the office does your procedure itself.
A four-step filter for a short list
Four checks will narrow the 24 rated offices to a short list. A 4.8 floor leaves 16, and 150 or more reviews on top of that leaves eight.
Step three matters in Reynoldsburg: 20 of the 47 listed practices have a website on file, and 19 of the 20 are rated offices. A missing website does not mean a weak dentist, and a stored web address plays no part in how the Score is assembled, but it does mean you will check hours and insurance by phone. Twenty of the 47 have posted hours on file, and all 47 have a phone number. For how our ratings are assembled, see how we rank practices.
Nearby places with their own directories
Six nearby places have their own Dental.me directories, built the same way: Pickerington (37 practices, 19 rated), Gahanna (42 practices, 27 rated), Bexley (6 practices, 2 rated), Blacklick (9 practices, 7 rated), Groveport (6 practices, 5 rated), Canal Winchester (17 practices, 11 rated). Together they list 117 practices, and Gahanna alone lists 42. Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live.
One last piece of context before you book: cost. Dental.me does not publish prices, and our national guide to dental costs gives no price ranges either; it lists what a quote depends on (the procedure, exam findings, insurance and materials), so ask each office for a written, itemised estimate. Then narrow to a shortlist on the Reynoldsburg directory.
How many dentists are in Reynoldsburg, OH?
Dental.me tracks 47 dental practices in Reynoldsburg, OH — 24 carry a public star rating that averages 4.3 stars, and 20 list a website. Compare the full ranked list on the Reynoldsburg dentists page.
Which is the top-rated dentist in Reynoldsburg?
By Dental.me Score, BUCKEYE PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY currently leads the Reynoldsburg list (4.9 stars, 764 reviews). Rankings update as ratings and profile data change, so compare a few offices before deciding.
How do I choose a good dentist in Reynoldsburg?
Compare the Dental.me Score alongside review volume, location, office hours, provider names, and website details, then shortlist three to five Reynoldsburg offices that fit your schedule, budget, and the care you need.
How does Dental.me rank Reynoldsburg dentists?
By an independent Dental.me Score built from each practice's Google star rating out of 100, held to a confidence level by its review volume, with exact review counts breaking ties and a verification lift that lets confirmed practices reach a perfect 100. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.