Finding a good dentist in Reidsville comes down to reading the numbers first: the Dental.me directory tracks 19 dental practices here, 14 of them carrying a public rating that averages 4.58 stars across 1,004 reviews. Start with the highest-rated offices below, confirm the specialty you need, then call to check availability.
How Reidsville’s dental numbers break down
Reidsville sits in Rockingham County in north-central North Carolina, a small city on US-29 roughly midway between Greensboro and the Virginia state line. 19 listed dental practices is a workable field, and the ratings are healthy: of the 14 offices with a public rating, nine sit at 4.8 stars or higher, two land in the 4.5-to-4.79 range, one is between 4.0 and 4.49, and two fall below 4.0. That concentration at the top is the single most useful fact in this guide, because it means most of your shortlist can come from the highest band alone.
The remaining five practices in the directory do not carry a public rating yet. That is common in a market this size and does not signal anything about the care itself; it usually means the office has not accumulated enough public feedback to display a score. When you weigh those offices, lean on the profile details and a direct phone call rather than a star number that is not there. The chart below shows exactly how the 14 rated practices distribute across the four rating bands.
The top-rated dental offices in Reidsville
The table below ranks the practices with the most public feedback in Reidsville, sorted by rating and then by review count. Four offices share a 4.9-star rating, so review volume becomes the tiebreaker there, and it separates them cleanly. Every practice name links to its full Dental.me profile, where you can see the address, contact details, and the office-confirmation status that feeds the Dental.me Score.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peter Grumbos DDS Reidsville PLLC | 4.9 | 344 | View profile |
| Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS | 4.9 | 231 | View profile |
| Reidsville Orthodontics | 4.9 | 100 | View profile |
| Wheless & Patton Dentistry | 4.9 | 31 | View profile |
| Reidsville Premier Dentistry | 4.8 | 91 | View profile |
| Paul R Barrett, DDS, PA | 4.8 | 32 | View profile |
Peter Grumbos DDS Reidsville PLLC leads the field on volume with 344 reviews at 4.9 stars, and Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS follows with 231, also at 4.9. For orthodontic care specifically, Reidsville Orthodontics holds a 4.9 across 100 reviews. The two 4.8-star offices, Reidsville Premier Dentistry and Paul R Barrett, DDS, PA, round out the shortlist with 91 and 32 reviews respectively. Any of these six is a defensible starting point; the right pick depends on the treatment you need and which office confirms an opening.
What the review counts tell you
Reidsville’s 1,004 public reviews are not spread evenly. The chart below plots the six most-reviewed practices, and it makes the shape of the market plain: two offices carry the bulk of the feedback, while the rest sit in a tighter cluster. A high review count paired with a high rating is the strongest combination on offer, because a 4.9 across 344 reviews has been tested by far more reviews than a 4.9 across 31. Both are top-band ratings; the difference is how much evidence sits behind each one.
It is also worth knowing how many offices have a rating at all. Fourteen of the 19 practices in Reidsville show a public score, which means about three-quarters of the local field is measurable on rating alone. The remaining five are still real options; you simply cannot compare them on stars, so a call and a look at the profile matter more for that group.
Website coverage and how to reach a practice
Twelve of the 19 Reidsville practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me; the other seven do not, which simply means you will reach them by phone or through the address on their profile rather than by clicking through to a site. A website is convenient for checking services and forms ahead of a visit, but its absence tells you nothing about the quality of care. For the seven offices without a URL on file, the Dental.me profile still carries the location and contact details you need to make the first call.
When you are ready to compare all 19 in one place, the Reidsville dental directory lists every practice with its rating, review count, and confirmation status side by side. That hub is the fastest way to move from this shortlist to a booked appointment, because it keeps the measurable signals, rating, review volume, and office confirmation, in a single view.
Reading a Reidsville profile before you call
Every one of the 19 Reidsville practices has a Dental.me profile, and each profile is built from the same signals so you can compare offices on equal footing. The rating and review count you see in the table above come straight from those profiles, but the page carries more than a star number. It shows whether the office has been confirmed, whether a website URL is on file, and where the practice sits within the city. For the nine offices in the top rating band, the profile is mostly a formality; you are confirming details before you book. For the five offices without a public rating, the profile does more work, because it is where you find the address and phone number that let you judge the office directly.
The Dental.me Score you see on a profile is earned, not purchased. It weighs the star rating, the volume of reviews behind that rating, and whether the office has confirmed its listing, so a high score reflects a strong rating backed by review volume. That is why a 4.9 across 344 reviews at Peter Grumbos DDS Reidsville PLLC reads differently from a 4.9 across 31 reviews at Wheless & Patton Dentistry: both are high, but one has far more evidence behind it. Only Featured placement can be paid for, and it never changes the underlying rating or the order in the table above, which is sorted purely by score and review count. When you read a Reidsville profile, you are reading the same honest signals this guide is built on.
Where Reidsville sits, and nearby options
Reidsville anchors the northern half of Rockingham County, with Eden a short drive north toward the Dan River and Mayodan and Madison to the west along NC-704 and US-220. Greensboro lies to the south down US-29, and the smaller communities of Summerfield and McLeansville sit between the two along that corridor. If the practice you want in Reidsville is booked out, widening your search by a few miles opens up a meaningfully larger field without a long drive.
The Dental.me directories for the surrounding towns work the same way this guide does. Start with the Eden dental directory just to the north, or check the Madison dental listings and the Mayodan dental directory to the west. Each lists local practices with the same rating and review signals, so you can compare an Eden or Madison office against your Reidsville shortlist on the same terms. For orthodontics in particular, casting the net one town over can be worth it when a specific treatment timeline matters.
How to choose the right dentist for your needs
With the data in front of you, a sensible process for Reidsville looks like this. First, decide what you actually need: a routine cleaning and checkup, a specific procedure, or orthodontic care. That choice narrows the field immediately, since Reidsville Orthodontics is the obvious first stop for braces or aligners, while a general office like Peter Grumbos DDS Reidsville PLLC or Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS covers everyday dentistry.
Second, read the rating alongside the review count, not on its own. A 4.9 backed by hundreds of reviews carries more weight than the same score backed by thirty, though both are high ratings. Third, confirm the practical details, insurance acceptance, new-patient availability, and location, on the profile and by phone before you commit. Finally, do not rule out the five unrated offices automatically; they lack a public score, which is not a verdict on them, and a direct call is the fastest way to judge fit. Used together, the rating bands, the review counts, and the office-confirmation status give you a clear, honest read on all 19 Reidsville practices.
Booking your first appointment in Reidsville
Once you have a shortlist, the mechanics of booking in a market this size are straightforward. Call during business hours and ask three questions: whether the office is accepting new patients, whether it takes your insurance, and how soon it can see you. Those answers, more than anything on a website, decide where you actually go. Because nine of the 14 rated Reidsville offices sit in the top band, you can afford to call two or three from that group and take the first solid opening rather than waiting weeks for one specific practice.
If you are moving to Reidsville or switching dentists, bring your prior records or ask the new office to request them; a general practice such as Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS or Reidsville Premier Dentistry can usually fold an existing history into a first cleaning. For a child’s braces evaluation or an adult aligner consult, Reidsville Orthodontics is the specialist stop, and orthodontic timelines run in months, so booking the consult early is worth it even if treatment starts later. Keep the Reidsville dental directory open while you call; it lets you cross off practices and move down your list without losing your place, and it is the same source the ranked table on this page draws from.
For anyone weighing Reidsville against the surrounding towns, the trade-off is simple. Staying in the city keeps you close to the two most-reviewed offices and the local orthodontist. Widening the search to Eden or Madison expands the field when timing is tight. Either way, the numbers that matter, 19 practices, 14 rated, a 4.58 average, and 1,004 reviews behind them, are all measurable, so your decision can rest on evidence rather than guesswork.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are in Reidsville, NC?
The Dental.me directory lists 19 dental practices in Reidsville. Fourteen of them carry a public rating, and those rated offices average 4.58 stars across a combined 1,004 reviews. The other five are listed but do not yet show a public score.
Which Reidsville dentist has the highest rating?
Four offices tie at the top with a 4.9-star rating: Peter Grumbos DDS Reidsville PLLC, Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS, Reidsville Orthodontics, and Wheless & Patton Dentistry. Peter Grumbos DDS leads on review volume with 344 reviews, followed by Cynthia A. Bolton, DDS with 231.
Is there an orthodontist in Reidsville?
Yes. Reidsville Orthodontics is listed in the directory with a 4.9-star rating across 100 reviews, making it the local specialist stop for braces and aligner consultations without needing to leave the city.
How many Reidsville dental practices have a website?
Twelve of the 19 Reidsville practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me. The remaining seven do not list a URL, so you would reach those offices by phone or through the address on their Dental.me profile.
What is the average dentist rating in Reidsville?
Across the 14 Reidsville practices that carry a public rating, the average is 4.58 stars, built on 1,004 total reviews. Nine of those offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher, so the field is concentrated near the top.
What if I can't find an opening with a Reidsville dentist?
Widen the search to the surrounding Rockingham County towns. The Eden directory sits just north, and Madison and Mayodan are a short drive west, each listing local practices with the same rating and review signals you see for Reidsville.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.