The Dental.me directory lists 28 dental practices in Port Jefferson Station, NY, and 20 of them carry a Google rating, averaging 4.45 stars. Below are the six practices with the highest Dental.me Score, the review counts behind them, and the service lists on file.
What the ratings tell you about Port Jefferson Station dentists
Of the 28 practices, 20 carry a Google rating and 8 do not; Dental.me does not record why, and a missing rating is not a mark against an office. The 20 ratings average 4.45 stars (a plain mean, each office counted once) across 2,022 reviews, and the median rating is 4.85. The review counts run from 387 down to one, and 6 of the 20 ratings rest on 14 reviews or fewer. Dental.me records a website URL for 16 of the 28, posted weekly hours for 15 and a phone number for all 28.
Split into bands, 12 ratings sit at 4.8 or higher, two between 4.5 and 4.79, three between 4.0 and 4.49, and three below 4.0. Four of the 12 at 4.8 or higher rest on eight reviews or fewer. Of the three below 4.0, Star Dental Care II PC (3.4) has 22 reviews and John Damaskos (3.6) 17; the third rests on one review. Leave those three out and the other 17 rated offices average 4.76.
Port Jefferson Station’s top six by Dental.me Score
The table lists the six Port Jefferson Station practices with the highest Dental.me Score, in Score order. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. Two of the six hold a 5.0, on 387 and 325 reviews. Click any name to open its full profile.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patrick J. Sabo, D.M.D. & Mark A. Rienecker, D.D.S., P.C. | 5.0 | 387 | View profile |
| Julia Nicolosi | 5.0 | 325 | View profile |
| Suffolk Pediatric Dentistry PC | 4.9 | 296 | View profile |
| Long Island Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Associates LLP | 4.8 | 165 | View profile |
| Karyn M. Halpern, D.M.D., P.C. | 4.9 | 146 | View profile |
| Gerald Cole, D.M.D., P.C. | 4.9 | 56 | View profile |
Patrick J. Sabo, D.M.D. & Mark A. Rienecker, D.D.S., P.C. ranks first, with a 5.0 on 387 reviews, the largest review record in Port Jefferson Station, and Julia Nicolosi second, with a 5.0 on 325. Suffolk Pediatric Dentistry PC (4.9 on 296) is third and Long Island Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Associates LLP (4.8 on 165) fourth; Karyn M. Halpern, D.M.D., P.C. (4.9 on 146) and Gerald Cole, D.M.D., P.C. (4.9 on 56) complete the six. The table leaves out two larger review records: Gabriel Iancu holds a 4.6 on 262 reviews and sits tenth by Score, and Concerned Dental Care of Port Jefferson, PLLC a 4.2 on 167, 15th.
How review volume is spread across local offices
The 20 rated practices hold 2,022 reviews. The two largest records, Patrick J. Sabo and Mark A. Rienecker’s practice (387) and Julia Nicolosi (325), hold 712 of them, 35%, and the six largest hold 1,602, or 79%. The chart below shows those six; two of them, Gabriel Iancu and Concerned Dental Care, are outside the Score top six.
A rating on a large review count is settled; on a small count, a few new reviews can still move it. A 5.0 on 387 reviews and a 5.0 on one print the same number. Read both columns side by side when you shortlist, and treat review depth as one input rather than the whole decision.
Website coverage and reaching an office
Dental.me has a website URL on file for 16 of the 28 practices, a little over half, and all 16 are rated offices. A missing URL means Dental.me has no web address recorded, not that the office has no site. Where a URL is on file you can often check services and new-patient forms before you call; for the other 12, the practice profile and phone number are your starting point. Dental.me has a phone number for all 28.
None of this is a judgment about the office itself; a practice with no website URL on file may still be well-reviewed. It simply means your first useful contact is a call rather than a click, so budget a few minutes to ask about availability, insurance, and whether they are taking new patients.
Service lists in Port Jefferson Station
Dental.me keeps 12 service lists for Port Jefferson Station: teeth whitening 6, cosmetic dentists 6, dental implants 4, pediatric dentists 4, endodontists 4, periodontists 3, emergency dentists 2, orthodontists 2, Invisalign 2, oral surgeons 1, dentures 1. Eleven of the 12 hold at least one office; the prosthodontist list is empty. 11 of the 28 practices are on at least one list. The chart below shows all 12.
Gabriel Iancu (4.6 on 262) is on eight of the 12 lists, the most in Port Jefferson Station, and Victoria E. Shack, DDS, PC (5.0 on one review) on six. Long Island Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Associates LLP is the only office on the oral-surgeon list. The orthodontist and Invisalign lists each hold the same two offices, Patrick J. Sabo and Mark A. Rienecker’s practice and Suffolk Pediatric Dentistry, and the teeth whitening and cosmetic lists hold the same six. A place on a list shows what an office lists, not how often it does that work, so ask whether the office does your procedure itself.
The Dental.me Score and neighboring directories
The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. Paid placements are clearly labeled as Featured and never change the organic order. Use the Score as a fast first filter, then read the underlying rating and review count for the specific offices you are weighing.
Dental.me lists three nearby directories: Port Jefferson (16 practices, 6 rated), Stony Brook (103 practices, 31 rated), Selden (16 practices, 10 rated). Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live. Each lists its rated practices on the same rating-and-review basis as the offices above.
Start from the full Port Jefferson Station dental directory to see all 28 listed practices, including the ones below the top six, then open the profiles that match your priorities. Whether you value the deepest review base, a pediatric focus, or a cosmetic specialty, the data here lets you make that call on numbers rather than guesswork.
How to choose your dentist here
Put the pieces together in order. Begin with the rating bands: 12 of the 20 rated offices sit at 4.8 or higher, four of them on eight reviews or fewer. Use the ranked table to shortlist two or three names, check each one’s review count, confirm whether a website URL is on file, and open any service list you need. Then confirm insurance and hours directly with the office. Dental.me does not record which insurance an office accepts. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are in Port Jefferson Station, NY?
Dental.me lists 28 dental practices in Port Jefferson Station. 20 carry a Google rating, and together the rated offices hold 2,022 reviews; the other 8 have no rating on file.
What is the average dentist rating in Port Jefferson Station?
The 20 rated practices average 4.45 stars. Twelve of them rate at 4.8 or higher, two fall between 4.5 and 4.79, three between 4.0 and 4.49, and three below 4.0.
Which Port Jefferson Station dental practice has the best rating?
Six offices show a 5.0, but only two pair it with a large review count: Patrick J. Sabo and Mark A. Rienecker’s practice, with 387 reviews, and Julia Nicolosi, with 325. The other four rest on eight reviews or fewer. By Dental.me Score, the Sabo and Rienecker practice ranks first.
Are there cosmetic or teeth-whitening dentists in Port Jefferson Station?
Yes. Six practices are on the cosmetic dentist list and six on the teeth whitening list, and the two lists hold the same six offices.
Do Port Jefferson Station dental offices have websites?
Sixteen of the 28 listed practices have a website URL on file, a little over half. For the rest, the practice profile and phone number are your starting point for questions about services and availability.
How does the Dental.me Score decide the rankings?
The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. Paid placements are clearly labeled as Featured and never change the organic order.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.