Quick answer: Nutley, NJ has 51 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 32 are rated on Google, averaging 4.56★ across 4,726 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: MK Periodontics & Implant Dentistry, PC, Shefali Pilar, Nutley Family Dentists, LLC. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.
| # | Practice | Google rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MK Periodontics & Implant Dentistry, PC | 5★ | 694 |
| 2 | Shefali Pilar | 4.9★ | 701 |
| 3 | Nutley Family Dentists, LLC | 5★ | 550 |
| 4 | Hollywood Pediatric Dentistry | 5★ | 518 |
| 5 | Dr. Thomas Torre DMD {Family, Cosmetic and Implant Dentistry } | 5★ | 280 |
Dental.me holds 51 dental practice listings for Nutley, New Jersey, and 32 carry a Google rating; Dental.me does not record why the other 19 do not. The 4.56 average is a plain mean: each rated row counts once, whether it holds one review or 701. Six rows below 4.0, with 26 reviews between them, pull it down; the other 26 rows average 4.92. Weighted by reviews, the same ratings average 4.94. The median rated row holds 31 reviews. A rating is not a measure of clinical quality, so read each rating beside the review count behind it.
By office, 24 of the 32 rated rows sit at 4.8 stars or higher, one (Konstantin Maltsen, 4.7 on 168 reviews) sits between 4.5 and 4.79, one between 4.0 and 4.49, and six sit below 4.0. By reviews, the 24 hold 4,525 of the 4,726 reviews (96%). The six below 4.0 hold 26, and none has more than 10. The top band mixes samples: 13 of its 24 rows hold 100 reviews or more, and eight hold 14 or fewer.
How the 32 rated rows break down
This chart counts rows in each rating band and the reviews each band holds.
A cut-off costs more than it looks. A 4.8 line drops Konstantin Maltsen, the 12th-largest record, and leaves no row on the endodontist list. A 100-review line leaves no row on the orthodontist or Invisalign lists, because the only rated row on them is Gabriel Ollins, a 5.0 on two reviews.
Nineteen of the 51 rows carry no Google rating in our data; Dental.me does not record why. An unrated row is unknown in this data, not shown to be weak, so ask it the same questions you would ask a rated office. Dental.me holds no review text, no review dates, no appointment-availability data and no insurance data, so it cannot say how recent a rating is or what reviewers wrote; the dates are on each office’s Google profile.
The six largest records by review count
Nutley’s 4,726 reviews are not spread evenly. The six largest records hold 3,016 of them (64%). A review count says how large the sample is, not how good the care is. Each office below links to its profile in the Nutley directory:
- Shefali Pilar — 4.9★ on 701 reviews, the most in Nutley.
- MK Periodontics & Implant Dentistry, PC — 5.0★ on 694 reviews; it is on the dental implants and periodontist lists.
- Nutley Family Dentists, LLC — 5.0★ on 550 reviews.
- Hollywood Pediatric Dentistry — 5.0★ on 518 reviews; it is on the pediatric dentist list.
- Dr. Thomas Torre, DMD — 5.0★ on 280 reviews; its name lists family, cosmetic and implant dentistry, but it is on none of the 12 Dental.me service lists. An unrated Evenly Orthodontics row at its address is on two.
- Philip Echo — 4.9★ on 273 reviews, with no URL on file and on no list, though its address line names a center for oral and maxillofacial surgery.
The Dental.me Score, which is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing, ranks MK Periodontics & Implant Dentistry first, then Shefali Pilar, Nutley Family Dentists, Hollywood Pediatric Dentistry, Dr. Thomas Torre and Barry Litwin (5.0 on 210). Five offices are in both groups; Philip Echo is sixth by review count and ninth by Score.
Rows, addresses and phone numbers
A row is a record, not proof of a separate office. The 51 rows hold 44 distinct phone numbers, and at least 12 of the 19 unrated rows give the phone number or street of a rated row, so totals on this page count listings, not distinct offices.
Five of the six rows below 4.0 give the same street address as a rated row at 4.8 or higher. Eight rows give 230 Centre St, including PERIOLLP (4.9 on 244), Dr. Richard Nejat (5.0 on 12), Gregory C. Perez DMD (4.8 on 4), Dr. Eugenie E. Lee (3.5 on 6) and Dr. Daniel Nejat (3.0 on 2). Six give 175 Franklin Ave, including All About Smiles Family Dentistry (4.9 on 153), QUALITY DENTAL ASSOCIATES (3.7 on 6, Suite 101) and Jenne Donald G DDS (1.0 on one review), which has the suite and number of All About Smiles. Three give 502 Franklin Ave: Dr. Thomas Torre (5.0 on 280), Spencer Schwartz (3.0 on one review) and an unrated Evenly Orthodontics row, whose URL names Thomas Torre. The sixth, WAYNE A. ARMENTI DMD PA (3.8 on 10), has its own address.
Other rows share a number or address. Dr. Yuliya Khodak (5.0 on 166) and Sundus Abudayyeh (5.0 on one review) give one number and 128 Franklin Ave. Shefali Pilar and an unrated Laurie Dimichele-Smorra row give one number at 4 and 10 Franklin Ave. Konstantin Maltsen and an unrated Chow David Y DDS row, both on the endodontist list, give 189 Franklin Ave. Sunshine Smiles and an unrated FEILER DENTAL ASSOCIATES row give 187 Chestnut St. Philip Echo and an unrated Oral & Facial Associates row give 187 Washington Ave, and ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL ASSOC OF NUTLEY (5.0 on 204), at 244 Chestnut St, has a URL at echooralsurgery.com. Dental.me has not confirmed how any of these rows relate, so call before treating two as one office or as two.
Two unrated rows do not read as dental offices: Yamahachi Dental Products USA, with a URL at ydp-usa.com, and Franciscan Sisters-St Elzbth. Both count in the 51. Dental.me has not checked them.
Nutley on the 12 Dental.me service lists
The 12 lists come from listing categories and show an association with a service, not a count of specialists. Here is how many Nutley rows are on each:
Ten rows are on the cosmetic dentists list and 10 on the periodontist list. Eight are on the dental implants list, and seven of those are also on the periodontist list. Five are on the emergency dentists list and 4 on the pediatric dentist list. The 3 on the teeth whitening list are all on the cosmetic list too. Three are on the endodontist list, the same 2 rows are on the orthodontist and Invisalign lists, and 2 are on the oral surgeon list. A place on a list shows a listing category, not how often an office does that work, so ask whether the office does your procedure itself, who would treat you, whether it takes your insurance and how soon it can see you.
Only 22 of the 51 rows are on any list. Sixteen rated rows on no list hold 988 of the 4,726 reviews (21%), including Dr. Thomas Torre, Score #5, Dr. Yuliya Khodak, Score #8, and Philip Echo, Score #9, so check those as well as the lists.
Several short lists rest on thin records. The orthodontist and Invisalign lists hold Gabriel Ollins (5.0 on two reviews) and the unrated Evenly Orthodontics row. Two of the three endodontist rows, Chow David Y DDS and Gregory Corso, are unrated. The oral surgeon list holds ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL ASSOC OF NUTLEY and unrated TeethNow Dental Implants New Jersey, which is also on the implant and periodontist lists. Elaine Tremarco, a 5.0 on three reviews with no URL, is on four lists, including emergency and pediatric. WAYNE A. ARMENTI DMD PA (3.8 on 10) is on the pediatric, cosmetic and whitening lists. Dental.me holds no availability data, so a place on the emergency list does not say how soon an office can see you.
Website URL on file
Twenty-four of the 51 rows have a website URL on file: 19 rated and five unrated. Thirteen rated rows, with 336 reviews between them, and 14 unrated rows have none. Philip Echo holds 273 of those 336. That records what Dental.me holds, not whether an office has a site, and a URL says nothing about the care.
Four checks for a Nutley shortlist
Four checks are below, using only the data Dental.me holds.
Start from the service you need, and check the rated rows on no list as well. Then read the review count: a 5.0 on 550 reviews (Nutley Family Dentists) rests on a far larger sample than a 5.0 on three, though neither is proof of better care. Do not make either a cut-off; Konstantin Maltsen (4.7 on 168) is a larger record than most of the 5.0s. Read the street and phone number, since two rows can be one office, and read the six below 4.0 by their counts and addresses. If a row is unrated, Dental.me does not record why, so ask it the same questions you would ask a rated office.
The ranking methodology explains how the Dental.me Score weighs ratings and review counts.
Nearby directories
The six towns this page links hold very different amounts: Clifton 145 rows (88 rated), Bloomfield 59 (38), Kearny 36 (20), Lyndhurst 23 (15), Belleville 22 (13) and Glen Ridge 4 (2). Montclair, which this page did not link, holds 60 (31). The denture and prosthodontist lists are empty here. All six towns have a row on the denture list, with Clifton at nine and Bloomfield at four. Clifton, Bloomfield and Lyndhurst have one row each on the prosthodontist list, and Montclair two. Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live.
The Nutley dentist directory holds all 51 rows over four pages, with four Featured cards first that do not follow the Score order, and it has no sort control. Dental.me does not publish prices, and our national guide to dental costs gives no price ranges either; it lists what a quote depends on (the procedure, exam findings, insurance and materials), so ask each office for a written, itemised estimate.
How many dentists are in Nutley, NJ?
Dental.me tracks 51 dental practices in Nutley, NJ — 32 carry a public star rating that averages 4.6 stars, and 24 list a website. Compare the full ranked list on the Nutley dentists page.
Which is the top-rated dentist in Nutley?
By Dental.me Score, MK Periodontics & Implant Dentistry, PC currently leads the Nutley list (5.0 stars, 694 reviews). Rankings update as ratings and profile data change, so compare a few offices before deciding.
How do I choose a good dentist in Nutley?
Compare the Dental.me Score alongside review volume, location, office hours, provider names, and website details, then shortlist three to five Nutley offices that fit your schedule, budget, and the care you need.
How does Dental.me rank Nutley dentists?
By an independent Dental.me Score built from each practice's Google star rating out of 100, held to a confidence level by its review volume, with exact review counts breaking ties and a verification lift that lets confirmed practices reach a perfect 100. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.