Home › Dental Guides › Dentists in Newburgh, IN: Local Guide

Dentists in Newburgh, IN: Local Guide

Published June 30, 2026 · dental.me editorial · How we verify

Finding a good dentist in Newburgh, Indiana starts with a directory of 21 dental practices, 13 of which carry a Google rating averaging 4.4 stars across 3,136 reviews. Start with the highest-reviewed offices below, confirm insurance and hours by phone, and use the ranked table to compare before you book.

How Newburgh’s dental directory breaks down

The Dental.me directory lists 21 dental practices in Newburgh. 13 carry a Google star rating; the other 8 have none (3 show zero reviews and 5 have no review count on file). That is more than a third of the local offices with no rating attached, so for those a phone call tells you more than any page will. Dental.me holds a phone number for all 21 practices and posted opening hours for 10 of them.

The 13 rated practices average 4.4 stars, but that single number hides a split. Nine of the rated offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher, none land in the 4.5 to 4.79 band, two fall between 4.0 and 4.49, and two rate below 4.0: a 3.2 on 69 reviews and a 1.0 on a single review. Without that one-review 1.0, the other 12 average 4.68. The chart below shows how the 13 offices distribute across the four rating tiers.

Rated Newburgh dentists by star band (13 total) 4.8 and up 9 4.5 to 4.79 0 4.0 to 4.49 2 Below 4.0 2 Each bar counts rated practices; 8 more offices are listed without a rating.

Alongside the ratings, it helps to know how many offices you can research online before you call. Of the 21 listed practices, 11 have a website URL on file with Dental.me, and 10 do not. All 11 offices with a URL are rated ones. A missing URL describes the record, not the office; for those you confirm services and hours by phone. The share below shows that split at a glance.

Practices with a website URL on file (21 total) 11 with a URL 10 without About 52% of Newburgh practices list a website URL you can review before calling. No URL on file means you confirm details by phone, not that the office lacks one.

The top-rated dentists in Newburgh

The table below lists the six most-reviewed practices in the Newburgh directory, in star-rating order and by review count within a rating. The same six are the top six by Dental.me Score, which puts James Woodyard third and Gerald Enlow fourth. Six offices hold a perfect 5.0: Family Dentistry, the most-reviewed office in town with 1,356 reviews, the Dale Sorenson practice at 509 and the Gerald Enlow practice at 275; the other three rest on 7, 3 and 1 reviews. Use the profile links to open full details for each.

Practice Rating Reviews Profile
Family Dentistry 5.0 1,356 View profile
Dale Sorenson 5.0 509 View profile
Gerald Enlow 5.0 275 View profile
James Woodyard 4.9 451 View profile
Newburgh Modern Dentistry LLC 4.8 246 View profile
Adam Guth 4.8 167 View profile

A perfect 5.0 backed by 1,356 reviews and a 5.0 backed by 275 both read as “top tier,” but the volume behind each rating tells you how settled that score is. The James Woodyard practice sits at 4.9 across 451 reviews, and both Newburgh Modern Dentistry LLC and the Adam Guth practice hold 4.8. Dental.me does not record which insurance an office accepts. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.

Reading the review counts, not just the stars

Newburgh’s 13 rated practices have gathered 3,136 reviews between them, and that volume is heavily concentrated. Family Dentistry alone holds 1,356 of them, 43 percent, and the six offices in the table hold 3,004, or 96 percent. The gap between the most-reviewed office and the rest is the single clearest pattern in Newburgh’s data, and the chart below plots the six leading offices side by side so you can see how uneven that distribution is.

Review count by practice (top six) Family Dentistry 1,356 Dale Sorenson 509 James Woodyard 451 Gerald Enlow 275 Newburgh Modern 246 Adam Guth 167 Bars show total reviews on file; these six account for most of the city’s 3,136.

A high review count does not automatically mean a practice is the right fit for you, but it does mean the star rating rests on a broad base of feedback rather than a handful of reviews. When two offices carry the same 5.0, the one with far more reviews has simply had that score tested more times. That is why the table orders by rating and then by review count within a rating, and why an office like the Adam Guth practice at 4.8 across 167 reviews still rests on a broad base.

Cosmetic dentistry and whitening in Newburgh

Dental.me sorts Newburgh practices onto 12 service lists. The two longest are cosmetic dentistry and teeth whitening, with five offices each, and they are the same five offices. The dental implant list holds four, periodontics and pediatric dentistry two each, and orthodontics, Invisalign and oral surgery one each. The dentures, emergency, endodontics and prosthodontics lists hold no Newburgh practice, so for those a nearby directory is the place to look. A list entry reflects the services a practice lists, not a specialist credential, so ask an office about its training.

The two longest of 12 lists Cosmetic dentists 5 Teeth whitening 5 Implants 4, periodontics 2, pediatric 2; four lists hold none.

To go straight to those lists, browse cosmetic dentists in Newburgh or teeth whitening providers in Newburgh. The two lists hold the same five offices, so open each profile to confirm the exact treatments before you book. For a complete view of every listed office and every service tag in town, the Newburgh dentist directory hub is the place to start.

Looking beyond Newburgh

Nearby towns have their own Dental.me directories. Evansville lists 127 practices (64 rated), about six times Newburgh’s 21. Boonville lists 3 (all rated) and Haubstadt lists 2 (both rated), so they add only a few names. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.

If a list is empty in Newburgh, the Evansville dentist directory is the much larger pool to check first. Each of these hubs uses the same rating and review data you see here, so you can carry your shortlist across town lines without losing the comparison.

How to choose and what to confirm

With 21 practices, 13 of them rated and 3,136 reviews on file, Newburgh gives you enough signal to build a shortlist quickly. Begin with the ranked table, pick two or three offices that fit your needs, and open their profiles for the full detail. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. The Newburgh directory hub opens with four listings marked Featured, shown out of Score order; after those it follows the Score. A Featured placement does not change a practice’s rating or Score.

Before you commit, call each finalist and confirm three things the directory cannot promise for you: that they accept your dental insurance or offer a plan you can use, that they are taking new patients, and that they can see you in a timeframe that works. For the 10 offices with no website URL on file, that call is also how you learn their full range of services and office hours. Dental.me does not record any of those three, so the call is the only way to know.

Frequently asked questions

How many dentists are there in Newburgh, IN?

The Dental.me directory lists 21 dental practices in Newburgh, Indiana. Of those, 13 carry a Google star rating and 8 are listed without one yet. Together the rated offices hold 3,136 reviews.

Which is the highest-rated dentist in Newburgh?

Six Newburgh practices hold a perfect 5.0 rating, three of them on 275 reviews or more: Family Dentistry with 1,356 reviews, the Dale Sorenson practice with 509, and the Gerald Enlow practice with 275. Family Dentistry is the most-reviewed office in the local directory.

What is the average dentist rating in Newburgh?

Across the 13 rated practices, the average is 4.4 stars. Nine offices rate 4.8 or higher, two fall between 4.0 and 4.49, and two rate below 4.0 (a 3.2 on 69 reviews and a 1.0 on one review). Without the one-review 1.0, the other 12 average 4.68.

Can I find a cosmetic dentist or teeth whitening in Newburgh?

Yes. Five Newburgh practices are on the cosmetic dentistry list, and the same five are on the teeth whitening list. Four are on the dental implant list. The dentures, emergency, endodontics and prosthodontics lists hold no Newburgh practice.

Do all Newburgh dental practices have a website?

No. Of the 21 listed practices, 11 have a website URL on file and 10 do not. A missing URL is not a mark against the office; it simply means you confirm services and hours by phone rather than online.

What if I can't find the right dentist in Newburgh?

Nearby directories add options. Evansville lists 127 practices, while Boonville (3) and Haubstadt (2) are smaller than Newburgh. All use the same rating and review data. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.

Find a dentist near you on dental.me. Compare practice details, hours, ratings, and the Dental.me Score across the directory.
Browse Indiana dentists   More dental guides →

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.