Dentists in New York, NY: Local Guide

Quick answer: New York, NY has 2,539 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 1,138 are rated on Google, averaging 4.61★ across 185,860 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Nathan Weinkranz, West Side Kids Dental, P.C., DENTAL HOUSE PLLC. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.

No American city gives you more dentists to choose from than New York. The five boroughs hold 2,539 dental practices in our directory — more than Los Angeles, more than Houston, more than any market we track. That sounds like a luxury until you actually need a root canal on a Tuesday afternoon and realize that “more choice” and “easier to choose” are not the same thing. This guide is built for the specific problem of finding a dentist in a city where the sheer volume works against you.

Start with the number that reframes everything else: of those 2,539 practices, only 1,138 carry enough Google review data for us to rate them with confidence. That is not a knock on the other 1,401 — many are new, boutique, or specialist offices that simply don’t accumulate reviews at the same pace. But it means the practical New York shortlist is roughly 45% of what a raw search returns. The other 55% is noise you have to filter, and most people don’t know to filter it. Between those 1,138 rated offices sit 185,860 Google reviews — the second-largest evidence base in this directory, behind only Houston. New York doesn’t lack information. It buries you in it.

Read the rating spread, not the average

New York’s rated practices average 4.61 stars, and that headline number is genuinely healthy. But an average is a trap in a market this large, because it hides how the practices actually cluster. When we break the 1,138 rated offices into bands, the picture gets useful: 751 practices sit at 4.8 stars or higher — that’s your true short list, the top 66%. Another 158 land in the solid 4.5–4.79 range. Then it drops off: 112 practices between 4.0 and 4.49, and 117 sitting below 4.0.

Here’s the takeaway most guides won’t give you: in New York you can afford to be ruthless. With 751 practices already at 4.8+, there is no reason to settle for a 4.2. The city’s density means an elite-rated office almost certainly exists within a few subway stops of you. The bottom two bands — 229 practices, roughly one in five rated offices — exist mostly so you know what to walk past.

It’s also worth understanding why New York’s average sits a shade below the very best markets. This is a churning, high-turnover city: practices open, change ownership, and rebrand constantly, and a small office that’s had a rocky year drags visibly on the numbers precisely because reviews here are so plentiful and so blunt. New Yorkers do not leave gentle feedback. That candor is exactly what makes the ratings trustworthy — a 4.9 earned across hundreds of reviews in a famously demanding market means something different here than a 4.9 in a quieter town.

The specialist depth is the real New York advantage

If you only need a routine cleaning, New York’s scale is almost beside the point — any of the 751 top-rated general offices will do. Where the city genuinely pulls ahead of every other market is specialist depth, and this is the part worth planning around. New York lists 734 practices offering dental implants and 465 periodontists — the deepest benches in this directory. It also carries 151 prosthodontists, the specialists who rebuild full mouths and manage complex restorations. Prosthodontics is a rare specialty almost everywhere; in most cities you’ll count them on one hand. New York gives you 151 to choose from.

That depth matters because complex dental work is where a bad match becomes expensive. For implants, full-mouth restoration, or orthodontics, you want a city with enough specialists that you can compare two or three before committing — and New York is one of the only places where that’s realistic across every specialty at once. Browse the full implant dentists in New York, the periodontists, or the prosthodontists if you’re facing restorative work. For families, the city carries 268 pediatric dentists; for straightening, 359 orthodontists and Invisalign providers. And when something breaks after hours, there are 256 emergency dentists across the boroughs.

The practices patients rank highest

Volume of reviews is its own signal in New York — a review count in the hundreds takes a long time to accumulate in a city this competitive. A handful of practices have done exactly that while holding a near-perfect rating, and they’re a sensible place to anchor your search:

• Nathan Weinkranz — 5.0 stars across 1,031 reviews, the most-reviewed top-rated general dentist in our New York data.
• West Side Kids Dental, P.C. — 5.0 stars, 1,005 reviews; a standout for families on the Upper West Side.
• Dental House PLLC — 5.0 stars across 798 reviews.
• Dr Koslovsky DDS PC — 5.0 stars, 707 reviews.
• Steven Schloss & Gary Klein DDS — 5.0 stars, 703 reviews.
• Gramercy Kids Smiles — 5.0 stars, 688 reviews; another strong pediatric option.

Notice how many of the top-reviewed offices are pediatric — New York parents review their kids’ dentists relentlessly, which is a gift when you’re vetting one. You can see all of these and the rest of the top-rated field on the New York dentist directory.

One caution about the top of any New York list: a huge review count is a strong signal, but it is not the only one. A brand-new specialist who just opened a practice may be excellent and simply hasn’t banked hundreds of reviews yet, while a very large group practice can accumulate volume through sheer size rather than high Google ratings. Read the count alongside the rating and, where it matters, the specialty. The right anchor is a practice that is both highly rated and highly reviewed — the six above clear that bar — but the next tier down, the 4.8-and-up offices with 100 to 400 reviews, is where a lot of New York’s genuinely great, less-hyped dentists live.

A four-step filter for a 2,539-practice city

The mistake New Yorkers make is opening a map, seeing forty pins in a ten-block radius, and picking whichever answers the phone first. Here is a faster, better process built for this specific market.

Step four is the one out-of-towners underrate. In New York, the “best” dentist you’ll never visit twice is worse than the very-good one four stops closer. Only 1033 of the 2,539 practices even list a working website, so proximity plus a rating often tells you more than a marketing page ever will. If Manhattan prices or wait times don’t suit you, the surrounding neighborhoods are genuinely close: compare dentists in Astoria, Long Island City, Sunnyside, Woodside, East Elmhurst, and Elmhurst — all a short ride out and often a different price bracket entirely.

What it costs, and how we rate

Price is the variable New York guides tend to dodge, because it swings wildly by borough and by specialty. Rather than quote figures that won’t match your quote, we keep a national reference on what dental work actually costs so you can sanity-check any estimate you’re handed. And if you want to understand exactly how the 4.8+ threshold and review-weighting behind this guide work, that’s documented in how we rank dentists. When you’re ready to browse the field yourself, start at the New York dentist hub and apply the four-step filter above — in a market this deep, a disciplined search beats a lucky one every time.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.