Finding a good dentist in Neenah, Wisconsin starts with the numbers: Dental.me tracks 26 dental practices across the city, 18 of which carry a rating that averages a remarkable 4.91 out of five stars. Start with the highest-rated, review-backed offices listed below, confirm each one takes your insurance, then book a first cleaning.
Neenah sits on the southern shore of Lake Winnebago in the heart of the Fox Valley, and for a city its size it is unusually well supplied with dental care. Twenty-six practices operate inside the city, and the ones that patients have rated cluster tightly at the top of the scale. This guide walks through exactly how those 26 offices break down, which ones hold the strongest ratings, where Neenah’s 2,231 total reviews are concentrated, and how to turn that data into a confident first appointment.
How dental care breaks down across Neenah’s 26 practices
Of the 26 practices Dental.me tracks in Neenah, 18 have accumulated enough feedback to carry a rating, while the remaining 8 are listed but not yet rated. That is a high rated-share for a city this size, and it means most of your realistic options come with a track record you can actually read before you call. Among the 18 rated offices, the distribution is striking: 16 sit at 4.8 stars or higher, 2 land in the 4.5-to-4.79 range, and none fall below 4.5. There is no cluster of weak, low-rated offices to steer around here.
What this tells a first-time searcher is that the deciding factor in Neenah is rarely avoiding a bad office. It is about matching one of many strong offices to your specific needs: location relative to your home or work, whether they accept new patients, your insurance, and how much review depth you want behind the star rating. The last of those is worth a closer look, because a 4.9 built on 400-plus reviews is a more settled signal than the same rating on a handful.
The top-rated dental practices in Neenah
The table below lists the six most-reviewed and highest-rated practices Dental.me tracks in Neenah, sorted by rating and then by review volume. Every office here holds a 4.8 or better, and three of them carry a perfect 5.0. Use it as your shortlist, then click through to a profile to see the full record.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Florek Henderson Dental LLC | 5.0 | 289 | View profile |
| Joseph Mcniel | 5.0 | 135 | View profile |
| Megan Wolfinger | 5.0 | 105 | View profile |
| Dentistry by Design | 4.9 | 431 | View profile |
| Marissa Keesler | 4.9 | 288 | View profile |
| RLJ Dental | 4.8 | 377 | View profile |
A quick way to read this list: Dentistry by Design holds the deepest record in the city, a 4.9 across 431 reviews, so its rating is the most road-tested. RLJ Dental is close behind on volume at 377. If a flawless score matters more to you than sheer volume, Florek Henderson Dental LLC pairs a perfect 5.0 with a substantial 289 reviews, an uncommon combination.
Where Neenah’s 2,231 reviews concentrate
Across all rated practices, Neenah offices hold 2,231 reviews. The six shortlisted above account for 1,625 of them, so most of the city’s documented experience sits with a handful of high-volume offices. The chart below shows how review depth stacks up among those six, which is the single best way to judge how settled each star rating really is.
Depth matters because it changes how you weigh a rating. A 4.9 spread across 431 or 288 reviews reflects a large and consistent body of experience, so it is unlikely to swing much. A perfect 5.0 backed by 105 or 135 reviews, like Megan Wolfinger or Joseph Mcniel, is still a strong signal, just a younger one. Neither is better in the abstract; the right choice depends on whether you value a spotless score or a long, settled track record.
Website access when you reach out to a Neenah office
Eighteen of Neenah’s 26 practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me, which is the same count as the number of rated offices. For the other 8, no website URL is recorded, so your fastest route to those is a phone call or a walk-in during posted hours. When a site is available, it is usually the quickest way to check whether an office is accepting new patients and which insurance plans it works with before you commit to a call.
A practical note: the absence of a website URL on file is a record about listing data, not a judgment on the office. Several of Neenah’s strongest practices are best reached by phone, and a short call is often enough to confirm availability, insurance, and the earliest opening for a cleaning or exam.
What a 4.91 citywide average means for your search
The 18 rated practices in Neenah average 4.91 out of five. That is an unusually high floor, and it reshapes how you should approach the search. In many places the task is separating a few strong offices from a long tail of mediocre ones. In Neenah the strong offices are the tail, so your energy is better spent on fit than on filtering.
Because the ratings are so compressed, small distinctions become the tiebreakers. When two offices both sit near 4.9, decide on review depth, distance from your home or workplace along Neenah’s main corridors, whether they are open evenings, and how quickly they can fit in a first visit. The Dental.me Score behind each listing weighs a practice’s rating, its review volume, and whether its office details are confirmed, among other signals, so it already folds much of that comparison into one number you can scan.
Looking beyond Neenah into the Fox Valley
Neenah does not sit alone. It shares a dense cluster of communities across the Fox Valley, and if your top Neenah pick is booked out or does not take your plan, the neighboring directories are a short drive away. Immediately adjacent is dental practices in Menasha, Neenah’s twin city just across the Fox River. To the northeast, Appleton’s dental directory is the largest hub in the region and widens your options considerably.
Continuing up the valley, you can also compare offices in Kimberly, Greenville, and Little Chute, all within the same metro. Casting a slightly wider net is especially useful for specialty needs or for finding an office with earlier new-patient availability than Neenah’s most in-demand practices can offer.
How to choose your Neenah dentist
Put the data to work in a simple sequence. First, open the Neenah dental directory and start from the shortlist above, since all six clear a 4.8 rating. Second, decide what you weight more heavily: a deep, settled record like Dentistry by Design’s 431 reviews, or a flawless 5.0 like the three perfect-scored offices. Third, confirm the practical fit by phone or, where a URL is on file, on the office website, covering insurance, new-patient status, and the soonest appointment.
Finally, book. Neenah’s advantage over larger metros is that nearly every documented option is a strong one, so the real risk is not choosing poorly but waiting too long to schedule a routine cleaning or exam. Use the ratings and review counts to narrow to two or three offices, make the calls, and lock in the first opening that fits your week. With 26 practices in the city and a 4.91 average across the rated ones, a confident choice in Neenah is well within reach.
Frequently asked questions
How many dental practices are there in Neenah, WI?
Dental.me tracks 26 dental practices inside Neenah. Of those, 18 have accumulated enough feedback to carry a star rating, while 8 are listed but not yet rated.
What is the highest-rated dentist in Neenah?
Three Neenah practices hold a perfect 5.0: Florek Henderson Dental LLC (289 reviews), Joseph Mcniel (135), and Megan Wolfinger (105). Florek Henderson pairs the 5.0 with the deepest review record of the three.
Which Neenah dental office has the most reviews?
Dentistry by Design has the deepest record in the city, holding a 4.9 rating across 431 reviews. RLJ Dental is next with 377 reviews at a 4.8 rating.
What is the average dentist rating in Neenah?
Across the 18 rated practices in Neenah, the average rating is 4.91 out of five. Sixteen of those offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher, and none fall below 4.5.
How do I contact a Neenah dentist that has no website listed?
Eighteen of Neenah’s 26 practices have a website URL on file. For the 8 without a URL on record, a phone call or a visit during posted hours is the fastest way to confirm availability and insurance.
What nearby cities should I check if I can't get an appointment in Neenah?
Neenah’s twin city Menasha is directly across the Fox River, and Appleton offers the region’s largest directory. Kimberly, Greenville, and Little Chute are also within the same Fox Valley metro.
How many dentists are in Neenah, WI?
Dental.me tracks 26 dental practices in Neenah, WI — 18 carry a public star rating that averages 4.9 stars, and 18 list a website. Compare the full ranked list on the Neenah dentists page.
Which is the top-rated dentist in Neenah?
By Dental.me Score, DENTISTRY BY DESIGN currently leads the Neenah list (4.9 stars, 431 reviews). Rankings update as ratings and profile data change, so compare a few offices before deciding.
How do I choose a good dentist in Neenah?
Compare the Dental.me Score alongside review volume, location, office hours, provider names, and website details, then shortlist three to five Neenah offices that fit your schedule, budget, and the care you need.
How does Dental.me rank Neenah dentists?
By an independent Dental.me Score built from each practice's Google star rating out of 100, held to a confidence level by its review volume, with exact review counts breaking ties and a verification lift that lets confirmed practices reach a perfect 100. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.