Montville, New Jersey lists 32 dental practices on Dental.me, and 18 of them have a Google star rating on file, averaging 4.92 out of five (an unweighted average of the ratings). Begin with that rated group, weigh review volume against the rating, and confirm the office handles your specific treatment need.
What Montville’s dental map actually looks like
Montville is a compact Morris County township, so its dental market is easy to read once the numbers are in front of you. Of the 32 practices on file, 18 have a Google rating, and those 18 share 2,057 reviews between them. The other 14 have no rating on file, so for them the profile is all there is to compare.
The rating picture is top-heavy. Among the 18 rated practices, 16 sit at 4.8 stars or higher, two land in the 4.5-to-4.79 band, and none falls below 4.5. Five of those 16 rest on two or fewer reviews, though, so the review count beside each rating matters as much as the rating.
Highest-rated Montville practices with more than 160 reviews
The table below lists the six practices rated 4.8 or higher with more than 160 reviews, sorted by star rating and then by review count. Four of them hold a perfect 5.0. Eleven practices in Montville hold a 5.0 in all; the next-largest 5.0 records outside the table are Montville Smiles (119 reviews) and Montville Orthodontics (100), and the other five rest on two reviews or fewer. The table below is sorted by star rating, not by the Score.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fields Cosmetic & Family Dentistry, LLC | 5.0 | 208 | View profile |
| John Mcnally | 5.0 | 191 | View profile |
| Krause Comprehensive Dental Care | 5.0 | 168 | View profile |
| Montville Dental Associates: Matthew Spatzner, DDS | 5.0 | 167 | View profile |
| Montville Oral Surgery Associates | 4.9 | 194 | View profile |
| Montville Center for Dentistry | 4.8 | 411 | View profile |
Read this table in two directions at once. A perfect 5.0 built on 208 reviews, as at Fields Cosmetic & Family Dentistry, is an average drawn from a substantial sample, and John Mcnally, Krause Comprehensive Dental Care, and the practice of Matthew Spatzner, DDS at Montville Dental Associates all hold that same perfect mark on 191, 168, and 167 reviews respectively. Montville Center for Dentistry sits at 4.8, a hair lower, but across 411 reviews, the largest count in the township by a wide margin. Montville Oral Surgery Associates holds a 4.9 across 194 reviews.
How the Dental.me Score differs from the star rating
When 16 of 18 rated offices sit at 4.8 or higher, a star rating alone stops being a useful sorting tool. The Dental.me Score on each profile is a separate figure that weighs a practice’s star rating, review volume, and limited verification signals. It is earned and never sold. A 5.0 on two reviews and a 5.0 on 200 look identical as star ratings; the review count beside each one is what tells them apart.
Featured placement can be paid for, is labeled as such, and cannot buy a higher rating or a higher Score. In a market this tightly clustered, the practical difference between the leaders comes down to review count and treatment fit rather than the star number on its own. Use the ratings to shrink 32 practices down to a shortlist, then let review volume and treatment fit break the ties.
Website coverage and how to reach these offices
Seventeen of Montville’s 32 practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me, a little over half. A website lets you check services and insurance before you call. The 15 with no website URL on file are reachable through the phone number and details on their Dental.me profile. Three of the 18 rated practices have no URL, and two of the 14 unrated ones do, so the website split does not track the rating split.
Whichever way you reach out, keep a short script ready: name the treatment you need, ask whether the office is taking new patients, and confirm they work with your insurance. Those three questions resolve most of the uncertainty before a first visit, whether you found the office through its website or through its profile on the Montville dentist directory. Dental.me holds no appointment-availability data, so ask each office about its soonest opening.
Matching a Montville dentist to your treatment
Because most of the ratings here are high, the more useful filter is the treatment you actually need. Montville’s category pages list eight offices for dental implant services in Montville, six for periodontal care, and six cosmetic dentists. Six practices are listed for whitening, and the orthodontist and Invisalign lists each hold the same five practices; three of those five have no Google rating on file.
The overlap between these categories is where a little planning helps. A single implant case can involve both periodontal and surgical work, and Montville Oral Surgery Associates (4.9 across 194 reviews) is on the implant list. If your goal is a cosmetic result, it is worth asking one Invisalign or cosmetic office to scope the whole plan rather than splitting it across two offices. Narrow by treatment first, then check the rating and review count of each practice that remains, since some listed practices have no rating on file.
A practical way to choose in five minutes
Many of Montville’s rated options look alike on paper, so a simple sequence helps. First, decide what you actually need this visit, whether it is a routine cleaning, an implant consult, an orthodontic evaluation, or a cosmetic plan, because the treatment you name trims the field from 32 practices to the handful listed for it. Second, sort the survivors by rating and look at the review count beside each one, treating a high rating on hundreds of reviews as sturdier evidence than the same rating on a few.
Third, open two or three profiles side by side. Montville Center for Dentistry, at 4.8 across 411 reviews, has the most reviews in town, while Fields Cosmetic & Family Dentistry and John Mcnally hold perfect 5.0 ratings on more than 190 reviews apiece. Fourth, check whether the office has a website URL on file if you prefer to confirm insurance and services before calling. Fifth, make the call with your three questions ready.
Looking just beyond Montville
If a niche procedure or timing sends you a few minutes down the road, the neighboring directories are worth a look. Towaco is part of Montville Township, but its own hub is small: four listings, one with a Google rating. Boonton to the west lists 11 practices (5 rated), and Parsippany to the south lists 52 (34 rated). Dental.me holds no appointment-availability data, so ask each office about its soonest opening.
Treat those nearby towns as an extension of your Montville shortlist rather than a replacement for it. Start with the 18 rated practices in the township, keep the treatment filter switched on, and widen the radius only when timing or a specialty demands it. With an unweighted average of 4.92 across the rated practices, the harder part in Montville is usually choosing among several highly rated offices, and the review count beside each rating is the clearest way to tell them apart.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are in Montville, NJ?
Dental.me lists 32 dental practices in Montville, New Jersey. Of those, 18 have a Google rating on file, and together they hold 2,057 reviews.
Which Montville dentist has the highest rating?
Eleven Montville practices hold a perfect 5.0 star rating; six of them have 100 or more reviews, and the other five have two or fewer. Among the 5.0-rated offices, Fields Cosmetic & Family Dentistry carries the most reviews at 208, ahead of John Mcnally (191), Krause Comprehensive Dental Care (168), and Montville Dental Associates (167).
What is the average dentist rating in Montville?
The 18 rated practices in Montville average 4.92 out of five, an unweighted average of the ratings. Sixteen of them sit at 4.8 stars or higher, two fall in the 4.5-to-4.79 band, and none is below 4.5.
Do Montville dentists offer dental implants?
Yes. Montville’s dental implant page lists eight practices, the largest of the township’s category lists. The periodontist page lists six and the cosmetic dentist page six.
How many Montville dental practices have a website?
Seventeen of Montville’s 32 practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me, a little over half. For the other 15, the phone number and details on their Dental.me profile are the way to reach them.
What if I can't get an appointment in Montville?
Dental.me holds no appointment-availability data, so ask each office about its soonest opening. If you need more options, Parsippany lists 52 practices (34 rated) and Boonton 11 (5 rated). Towaco is part of Montville Township; its own hub lists four practices.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.