Dentists in Mayfield Heights, OH: Local Guide

Quick answer: Mayfield Heights, OH has 42 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 22 are rated on Google, averaging 4.75★ across 3,935 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Douglas Leavitt, Fatima Saeed, Nemeth Family Dental Care. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.

Mayfield Heights is an eastern Cuyahoga County suburb with long specialty lists. Dental.me tracks 42 dental practices here. Sixteen are on the dental implants list, nine on the periodontists list, eight on the oral surgeons list and six on the endodontists list. These are category listings, not a measure of how much of each service an office performs. If you’re searching for the best dentist in Mayfield Heights, start from the service you need.

Here’s the ratings picture. Of the 42 practices, 22 carry a Google rating in our data — and those 22 hold a combined 3,935 reviews at an average rating of 4.75. Fifteen of the 22 scored offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher. Only two land below 4.5: Ali Taghizadeh Jazdani (4.1) and Scott Alperin (3.9, on 15 reviews). Jazdani’s 845 reviews are the largest count in the city.

The market at a glance

Two of those tiles deserve a second look together. Twenty-one of the 42 practices — exactly half — maintain a website, and Dental.me does not record why the rest have no site. Most of the gap sits among unrated offices: 20 of the 22 rated practices have a website on file, and 19 of the 21 without one carry no rating. Dental implants is the longest of the city’s 12 service lists, at 16 practices, ahead of cosmetic dentistry at 9.

What patients are actually rating

When 68% of a city’s scored practices clear 4.8 stars, the rating scale stops sorting high from low and starts sorting very high from high. Here is how the 22 scored offices distribute:

The practical read: a 4.6-star office in Mayfield Heights is well rated, but it sits in the bottom third of the rated field. Use the bar above as a calibration tool — when you shortlist, don’t stop at “over four stars,” because nearly everyone here clears it. Look instead at review volume, which is where the leaders separate.

The practices leading on volume and score

Ratings tell you sentiment; review counts tell you how much evidence sits behind that sentiment. A handful of Mayfield Heights offices combine both — near-perfect scores and hundreds of reviews — and those are the best-documented starting points for a new patient.

The two largest review counts in Mayfield Heights sit outside the top band: Ali Taghizadeh Jazdani (4.1 on 845 reviews) and Dr. Tabachnik & Associates (Richmond) (4.5 on 701). Together they hold 1,546 of the city’s 3,935 reviews (39%). Among the 4.8-and-up offices, Douglas Leavitt has the most, 550 reviews at a 4.9 average. Next, Fatima Saeed holds 4.9 across 350 reviews, and Nemeth Family Dental Care carries 311 at the same 4.9. Complete Smile Care — Drs. Calabrese, Sheridan & Hilal mirrors that with 307 reviews at 4.9. For orthodontics, Success Orthodontics holds 4.9 on 151 reviews, while Rebecca L. Robbins DDS rounds out the leaders at 4.8 over 216 reviews. These six top-band offices are a starting point; the tie-breaker is fit — who does the specific work you need, and when they can see you.

A specialist market: what’s available and how deep

Mayfield Heights rewards a service-first search because each of the directory’s 12 service lists has at least two practices on it. The shortest are prosthodontists (2) and pediatric dentists (4).

Read this chart as a map of your options, not just a tally. Because implant providers lead the field, an implant consult should be a shopping trip, not a settle-for-whoever call — get two or three opinions on the plan and the price. Reconstructive and surgical needs are well covered too, between nine periodontal practices, eight oral-surgery offices, and six endodontic providers for root canals. On the elective side, cosmetic dentistry and orthodontics list nine and six practices. The emergency list is short: five offices. It is a category listing and Dental.me holds no availability data, so if you’re prone to dental emergencies, pick an emergency office and ask how it handles urgent visits before you’re in pain, not during.

How to choose, given all this

With 21 of the 22 rated offices at four stars or more, the rating floor filters little, so filter for match first and let the ratings and review counts break ties. The path below is the sequence we’d follow.

Step four means a phone call, and half the practices here (21 of 42, most of them unrated) have no website on file. A five-minute conversation about whether they take your insurance, how they stage an implant or a crown, and what the all-in cost looks like will separate the offices faster than any star rating. Ask each office for that all-in figure as a written, itemised estimate; our national guide to dental costs publishes no prices, but it lists what a quote depends on.

The website gap

One pattern worth naming explicitly: four of the largest review counts are listed under an individual dentist’s name: Ali Taghizadeh Jazdani (4.1, 845), Douglas Leavitt (4.9, 550), Fatima Saeed (4.9, 350) and Rebecca L. Robbins (4.8, 216). The directory does not record practice size, ownership or hours, so ask each office which clinician you would see, and if your schedule is inflexible, ask any office you call about evening and weekend hours.

The website gap reinforces the point. Because only 21 of 42 practices maintain a site, you can’t always vet these offices online — there may be no fee schedule, no new-patient form, sometimes not even posted hours. Don’t read the absence of a slick website as a red flag; the rating and the review count we publish are recorded independently of whether a site exists. It simply means the phone does the work the web would elsewhere. When you call, ask directly whether they’re accepting new patients, which insurance networks they’re in, and how they handle after-hours emergencies — the three questions a missing website leaves unanswered. If pricing is your main concern, our dental cost guide lists what a quote depends on, so ask for the estimate in writing on that call.

Looking just beyond the city line

Mayfield Heights sits among other eastern Cuyahoga suburbs. If your shortlist comes up short, it’s worth widening the net to Lyndhurst, Mayfield Village, Highland Heights, South Euclid, or Mayfield. Together these five directories list 65 practices: Lyndhurst 35 (26 rated), Highland Heights 13, South Euclid 10, Mayfield Village 6 and Mayfield 1.

The bottom line for Mayfield Heights: 15 of the 22 rated offices sit at 4.8 or higher, but the two largest review counts belong to a 4.1 and a 4.5. Start from your specific need, lean on review depth to rank the contenders, and use a call or two to confirm fit. When you’re ready to browse the full field, the Mayfield Heights directory lists all 42 practices with their current ratings and services.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.