Finding a good dentist in Gillette starts with the numbers: the Dental.me directory tracks 20 dental practices across the city, 12 of them carrying a Google star rating, and those rated offices average 4.58 out of five (an unweighted average of the ratings). This guide shows you how to read that field.
Gillette is a compact, self-contained dental market, which is good news for anyone choosing a provider here. You are not sorting through hundreds of near-identical listings; you are weighing a short, knowable roster where the strongest offices are easy to identify and the differences between them are meaningful. Below, every figure comes straight from the current Dental.me data for Gillette, and every practice named links to its full profile so you can check the details yourself.
What the Gillette dental field looks like right now
Gillette anchors northeast Wyoming as the seat of Campbell County, and its dental roster is small enough to review in one sitting. Of the 20 practices Dental.me lists inside the city, 12 have a Google rating on file. The remaining eight appear in the directory without a rating, so they are listed without a number rather than judged. Among the 12 rated offices, the distribution leans decisively high: eight sit at 4.8 stars or above, one lands between 4.5 and 4.79, one falls between 4.0 and 4.49, and two rest below 4.0.
Those two lower-scoring offices are the reason the citywide average lands at 4.58 rather than climbing higher. It is a useful reminder that a headline average blends everything together; in a field this size, one or two outliers move the number visibly. That is exactly why looking at the band-by-band picture, and then at individual practices, tells you more than the single average ever can.
Highest-rated Gillette practices with more than 200 reviews
The table below lists the six Gillette practices rated 4.8 or higher with more than 200 reviews, sorted by star rating and then by review count. Four practices in Gillette hold a perfect 5.0; the two outside the table are Bennion Lambourne Orthodontics (41 reviews) and Graham Family Dental (6). A 5.0 built on hundreds of reviews is a stronger signal than a 5.0 built on a handful, so read the two columns together. The table above is sorted by star rating, not by the Score.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dental Care Center PC | 5.0 | 574 | View profile |
| Meyer and Dana Orthodontics Gillette, PLLC | 5.0 | 292 | View profile |
| Powder River Dental | 4.9 | 518 | View profile |
| Mountain West Dental | 4.9 | 393 | View profile |
| Pronghorn Family Dentistry LLC | 4.8 | 565 | View profile |
| Synergy Dental Center, P.C. | 4.8 | 564 | View profile |
Dental Care Center PC tops the list with a perfect 5.0 across 574 reviews, the largest review count of any 5.0-rated office in Gillette. Meyer and Dana Orthodontics Gillette, PLLC also holds a 5.0, over 292 reviews, and its name signals an orthodontic focus worth noting if braces or aligners are what you need. Just behind them, Powder River Dental and Mountain West Dental each hold 4.9. Pronghorn Family Dentistry LLC and Synergy Dental Center, P.C. round out the group at 4.8, on 565 and 564 reviews, the second- and third-highest totals in the city.
How many Gillette offices list a website
Of the 20 practices in the directory, 10 have a website URL on file. The website field is a small but practical detail: an office with a listed site gives you a direct way to check services, staff, and new-patient forms before you ever pick up the phone. For the other 10, no website URL is on file in the directory, which simply means you will rely on the profile page and a call to learn more.
Notice that a missing website URL says nothing about the quality of care. Most offices without a listed site are unrated (7 of 10), so treat the website column as a convenience factor, not a verdict.
Reading review volume across town
Gillette’s rated dental practices have collected 3,183 reviews in total, and the way that volume is spread matters. The six offices in the table account for 2,906 of them, 91 percent, which means their ratings rest on hundreds of reviews each rather than a thin sample. The chart below shows the review count behind each of those six practices, ordered from the deepest record to the lightest.
Dental Care Center PC, Pronghorn Family Dentistry, and Synergy Dental Center each sit above 560 reviews, and Powder River Dental is not far behind at 518. When a rating this high is backed by a record this deep, a single unusual visit barely moves the rating, so the number you see rests on a large sample of reviews rather than a thin one that a few new reviews could swing.
Specialty care in Gillette
Beyond routine cleanings and fillings, Gillette offers a reasonable spread of specialty and cosmetic options. The directory records five practices offering cosmetic dentistry, five offering teeth whitening, and four offering dental implants. If you are weighing a specific procedure, start from these focused lists rather than the general roster.
You can browse each specialty directly: the cosmetic dentists in Gillette, the offices offering teeth whitening in Gillette, and the practices providing dental implants in Gillette. Three of the table’s offices, Powder River Dental, Mountain West Dental, and Pronghorn Family Dentistry LLC, appear on all three lists, so a practice you already like may handle the cosmetic or restorative work you are considering.
Looking beyond Gillette
A few nearby Wyoming towns fall within reach if you want to widen the field, though only one adds much depth. Sheridan, to the northwest along I-90, lists 40 practices, 18 of them rated. The others are small: Moorcroft (1 listing) and Sundance (2) to the east toward the Black Hills, Buffalo (3) to the west, and Newcastle (3) to the southeast. Each links to its own Dental.me directory so you can compare ratings and specialties the same way you would within Gillette.
How to narrow the Gillette field
Start with the full Gillette dental directory and let the data narrow the field before you make a single call. The Dental.me Score on each profile is a separate figure that weighs a practice’s star rating, review volume, and limited verification signals. It is earned and never sold. Featured placement can be paid for, is labeled as such, and cannot buy a higher rating or a higher Score. Shortlist two or three offices that pair a strong rating with a deep review count, confirm they handle the specific care you need, and then call to check insurance. Dental.me holds no appointment-availability data, so ask each office about its soonest opening.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are there in Gillette, WY?
The Dental.me directory tracks 20 dental practices in Gillette. Of those, 12 have a Google rating on file, while the other eight are listed without a rating.
Which Gillette dentist has the highest rating?
Four practices hold a perfect 5.0. Dental Care Center PC has the most reviews behind it (574), followed by Meyer and Dana Orthodontics Gillette, PLLC (292); Bennion Lambourne Orthodontics (41) and Graham Family Dental (6) rest on far fewer.
What is the average dentist rating in Gillette?
Across the 12 rated practices in Gillette, the average rating is 4.58 out of five. Eight of those offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher, which pulls the citywide average up despite two offices below 4.0.
How many Gillette dental offices have a website?
10 of the 20 practices in Gillette have a website URL on file. For the remaining 10, no website URL is listed, so you would rely on the Dental.me profile page and a phone call to learn more.
Where can I find cosmetic dentistry or implants in Gillette?
Gillette has five practices offering cosmetic dentistry, five offering teeth whitening, and four offering dental implants. You can browse each specialty list directly from the Gillette directory to compare ratings and review counts.
What if I can't find the right dentist within Gillette?
Nearby Wyoming towns each have their own Dental.me directory, including Moorcroft, Sundance, Buffalo, Sheridan, and Newcastle. Sheridan, with 40 practices, is the only one with a large roster; the other four list three practices or fewer each.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.