To find a good dentist in Garden City, start with the 25 dental practices Dental.me tracks across the city, 13 of which carry a Google rating; those ratings average 4.07 stars. Compare those rated offices by score and review count, confirm a website is on file, then shortlist two or three to call.
What Garden City’s dentist numbers actually show
Garden City, the Finney County seat in southwest Kansas, has 25 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. Thirteen of those carry a Google star rating; the remaining 12 have no rating on file, and Dental.me does not record why. The 13 rated practices average 4.07 stars together, but that figure hides a wide spread. Three offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher, four land in the 4.5-to-4.79 range, three fall between 4.0 and 4.49, and three sit below 4.0. In other words, the citywide average is pulled down by the lowest band, and the offices near the top rate well above the 4.07 figure. The three below 4.0 are Curtis Taylor (2.9 on 57 reviews), First Dental (2.8 on 17) and Dr. Richard Potts (1.0 on a single review). That is why a single average is a starting point, not a verdict: in a directory this size, you can read every rated office one by one.
Garden City’s highest-rated dental practices
The table below lists the top six practices on the Dental.me Score, sorted here by star rating and then by review count. Three of them hold 4.9 or higher, and only Michael Richard holds 5.0. The review counts at the top are concentrated: Erendira Baltierrez Razo alone holds 1,303 of the city’s 3,060 Google reviews (43%). Jeffrey Stasch (4.6 on 190 reviews) ties Jay Keltner on the Score and is not in the table. Use the table as a shortlist, then open each profile before you call.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Richard | 5.0 | 443 | View profile |
| Erendira Baltierrez Razo | 4.9 | 1,303 | View profile |
| Jake M Juhl DDS | 4.9 | 65 | View profile |
| Michael P.harris, D.D.S.,P.A. | 4.7 | 736 | View profile |
| Joshua Williams | 4.7 | 13 | View profile |
| Jay Keltner, D.d.d. P.A. | 4.6 | 197 | View profile |
A few things stand out. Michael Richard holds a perfect 5.0 across 443 reviews, the only 5.0 rating in the city. Erendira Baltierrez Razo carries a 4.9 across 1,303 reviews, by far the deepest review history in the city. Jake M Juhl DDS also holds a 4.9, but across a much smaller 65 reviews, so that score rests on far fewer reviews. Michael P.harris, D.D.S.,P.A. pairs a 4.7 with 736 reviews, the second-largest sample here, while Joshua Williams shares that 4.7 with only 13 reviews on file. Jay Keltner, D.d.d. P.A. rounds out the shortlist at 4.6 across 197 reviews. When two offices share a rating, the one with more reviews gives you a steadier read.
Website coverage and confirming an office
Of the 25 practices in the directory, 10 have a website URL on file and 15 do not; all 10 URLs belong to rated offices. That does not mean 15 offices lack a website in real life; it means Dental.me has not recorded one for them, so you may need a quick phone search or call to confirm hours, services, and whether they are accepting new patients. When an office does have a URL on file, it is the fastest way to verify that a practice is active and to see what it offers before you commit to a visit. Treat the presence of a website URL as one signal among several, alongside the star rating and the depth of the review history.
Where Garden City’s 3,060 reviews sit
Across the rated practices, Garden City has 3,060 total reviews on file, and they are heavily concentrated. Erendira Baltierrez Razo carries 1,303 of them on a 4.9 rating, and Michael P.harris, D.D.S.,P.A. adds 736 on a 4.7. Together those two offices hold roughly two-thirds of every review in the city. Michael Richard’s 443 reviews back a perfect 5.0, and Jay Keltner, D.d.d. P.A. contributes 197. At the smaller end, Jake M Juhl DDS (65) and Joshua Williams (13) have far shorter histories. A deep review count gives a rating more weight; a thin one can still be high but rests on fewer data points, so read those profiles closely.
Specialty listings in Garden City
If you need more than routine cleanings and fillings, the specialty lists matter, and in Garden City they are short. Five practices list dental implants, the longest list in the city. Three list cosmetic dentistry (the same three that list teeth whitening), two list pediatric dentistry, two list oral surgery, and one each lists periodontics, endodontics, orthodontics (the same office as the Invisalign list) and emergency care. No Garden City practice lists dentures or prosthodontics. Start with the implant practices whose rating and review count you are comfortable with, then confirm the specific procedure you need when you call. You can browse the full list on the Garden City dental implants directory.
Looking just beyond Garden City
Garden City’s 25 listed practices are more than any of the nearby directories below, which are small, but they can still give you a second opinion or a provider closer to where you actually spend your week. To the north sits Scott City (2 practices), and further west you will find Leoti (1) and Ulysses (4). The larger option is Dodge City (13) to the east along US-50, while Syracuse (1) lies west toward the Colorado line. Each has its own directory hub where you can compare local practices the same way you would in Garden City.
How to choose, step by step
Put the pieces together and the process is straightforward. First, open the Garden City dental directory and scan the 13 rated practices, ignoring the raw 4.07 average and looking instead at the star bands. Second, favor offices that pair a high rating with a deep review count, since those scores rest on more feedback: Erendira Baltierrez Razo and Michael P.harris, D.D.S.,P.A. both clear 700 reviews, while Michael Richard holds a perfect score on 443. Third, check whether a website URL is on file so you can verify hours and services quickly. Fourth, if you need implants, filter to the five practices that list them. Finally, shortlist two or three and call to confirm they are accepting new patients and take your insurance. The Dental.me Score weighs star rating, review volume, and whether an office is confirmed, so a high Score reflects those public inputs; it does not measure clinical quality.
A note on how these rankings work
The order here is earned, not purchased. A practice cannot pay to raise its Dental.me Score or move up the ranked table; only the separate Featured placement can be paid for, and it never changes the underlying rating or review numbers you see above. That is what lets you treat the table as an honest read of Garden City’s rated dentists.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are there in Garden City, KS?
Dental.me tracks 25 dental practices in Garden City. Thirteen of them carry a star rating, and the remaining 12 have no rating on file yet.
Which Garden City dentist has the highest rating?
Michael Richard holds a perfect 5.0 across 443 reviews. Erendira Baltierrez Razo and Jake M Juhl DDS both hold 4.9, with 1,303 and 65 reviews respectively.
What is the average dentist rating in Garden City?
The 13 rated practices average 4.07 stars, but that spans three offices at 4.8 or higher and three below 4.0, so the top tier scores well above the citywide average.
Which Garden City dentist has the most reviews?
Erendira Baltierrez Razo has the deepest history with 1,303 reviews on a 4.9 rating, out of 3,060 total reviews across all rated practices in the city.
Can I find a dentist for dental implants in Garden City?
Yes. Five of the 25 tracked Garden City practices list dental implants among their services, so you can compare implant providers by rating and review depth.
Do all Garden City dental practices have a website?
Dental.me has a website URL on file for 10 of the 25 practices. For the other 15 no URL is recorded, so you may need to call to confirm hours and services.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.