Quick answer: Fishkill, NY has 46 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 24 are rated on Google, averaging 4.35★ across 3,150 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Madeline Utterback, Main Street Dentistry, Fishkill Dental Studio. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.
| # | Practice | Google rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Madeline Utterback | 5★ | 223 |
| 2 | Main Street Dentistry | 4.9★ | 192 |
| 3 | Fishkill Dental Studio | 4.9★ | 112 |
| 4 | Fishkill Dental Associates | 4.9★ | 102 |
| 5 | Donald Stammer | 4.9★ | 98 |
Fishkill is a small village with plenty of dental choice. The directory maps 46 dental practices in Fishkill. Twenty-four of them carry a Google rating, they have gathered 3,150 Google reviews between them, and the town-wide average is 4.35 stars. Nine of the 24 sit at 4.8 or higher while four sit below 4.0, which is why a little filtering goes a long way.
The shape of the town’s dental market
Nine of the 24 rated offices — nearly four in ten — hold a 4.8-star average or higher, though three of the nine rest on 14 or fewer reviews. You are choosing among several well-rated offices, and the harder question is fit — location, services, and how a practice handles insurance. A rating is an average of what reviewers chose to post; it does not measure clinical quality.
The one caveat worth naming: only 17 of the 46 practices have a website URL on file, and 14 of the 17 belong to rated offices. Nearly two-thirds of the field has no URL on file. A directory that lists every office, with its rating and specialty listings, surfaces the offices that never listed a homepage. It also means the search order in Fishkill is reversed from a big city: start from the full list and work outward, rather than relying on a web search alone.
There is a second number under that 4.35 town average that is easy to miss. Twenty-two of the 46 practices carry no Google rating at all, and 19 of those 22 have no website URL on file either. A missing rating says nothing about the care. Treat “unrated” as “unknown,” not “avoid,” and let a phone call rather than a star count settle it.
The Dental.me Score’s top six in Fishkill
These six lead the Dental.me Score. They are not the six most-reviewed offices: Family Dental Group of Fishkill has the most reviews in town (4.5 on 1,344) and is not among them.
- Dr. Madeline Utterback holds a 5.0 rating across 223 reviews and is #1 on the Dental.me Score.
- County Dental at Fishkill — 634 reviews at a 4.7 average, the second-largest review count in Fishkill after Family Dental Group of Fishkill (1,344).
- Main Street Dentistry — 4.9 stars over 192 reviews.
- Fishkill Dental Studio — 4.9 stars over 112 reviews.
- Fishkill Dental Associates — 4.9 stars over 102 reviews.
- Dr. Donald Stammer — 4.9 stars over 98 reviews.
Notice the pattern: the two largest review counts in town belong to offices rated 4.5 and 4.7, while the 4.9 and 5.0 offices on this list rest on 98 to 223 reviews. Neither is objectively better, and knowing which you want narrows the list fast.
How to read a Fishkill star rating
Because many offices here score high, the star number alone is a weak tiebreaker. A 5.0 built on three reviews tells you little; a 4.7 built on 634 is an average of many separate reviews, so a few new ones barely move it. Weigh volume alongside the average, then decide on the things a rating cannot capture.
What can a rating never tell you? Whether the office takes your specific insurance plan (in-network status affects your out-of-pocket cost). Whether they run on time or routinely stack appointments. How they handle a dental emergency at 6pm on a Friday. Whether the hygienist you click with will still be there next year. Those are questions for a five-minute phone call, and a shortlist of three or four offices keeps those calls manageable. A useful script: ask whether they are accepting new patients, whether your plan is in-network, what a new-patient exam and cleaning runs before insurance, and how they triage same-day pain. The answers tell you things no rating can.
Specialty care without leaving the corridor
Fishkill’s specialty listings mean you can start your search for specialized work in town. Within the town itself:
- Seven practices list dental implants, the longest specialty list in town; all four periodontics listings and both oral surgery listings are among them.
- Six offices list teeth whitening.
- Five offices list cosmetic dentistry, all of them also on the whitening list.
If your reason for searching is a specific procedure rather than a routine cleaning, start from the specialty list, not the general one — it narrows 46 options to the offices that list the service you need. The other lists are short: periodontics 4, pediatric dentistry 3, emergency care 3, orthodontics 2 (the same two offices as Invisalign), endodontics 2, oral surgery 2 and dentures 1; no Fishkill practice lists prosthodontics. If cost is the deciding factor, our national guide to what drives dental costs is a useful first read before you call for quotes; it publishes no prices.
One note on implants in particular: with seven offices on the implant list, you can compare two or three written quotes and get more than one consultation before committing to a case. Ask up front whether the same practice handles the surgical placement and the final crown, or whether part of the work is referred out. For cosmetic work, ask to see before-and-after photos and read what reviews say about the look of the result.
If Fishkill doesn’t have your match, the neighbors do
Fishkill sits at the center of a tight ring of Hudson Valley and Dutchess/Putnam towns, most a short drive away. If your insurance network, a specific specialist, or simple scheduling sends you a little farther afield, these hubs are the natural next look:
- Beacon (8 practices) — just across the ridge to the west.
- Wappingers Falls (27) — to the north.
- Hopewell Junction (30) — immediately east along Route 82.
- Cold Spring (4) and Cornwall (3) — south into Putnam and across the river.
- Newburgh (59) — the largest of these, across the Hudson.
Your next step
The efficient path in a town this dense is not to research all 46 offices — it is to filter. Browse the full list of Fishkill dentists, check for the service you need and the ratings you trust, and shortlist two or three from the 4.8-plus tier before you pick up the phone. Curious how these rankings are built? Read how we rank dentists.
How many dentists are in Fishkill, NY?
Dental.me tracks 46 dental practices in Fishkill, NY — 24 carry a public star rating that averages 4.4 stars, and 17 list a website. Compare the full ranked list on the Fishkill dentists page.
Which is the top-rated dentist in Fishkill?
By Dental.me Score, Madeline Utterback currently leads the Fishkill list (5.0 stars, 223 reviews). Rankings update as ratings and profile data change, so compare a few offices before deciding.
How do I choose a good dentist in Fishkill?
Compare the Dental.me Score alongside review volume, location, office hours, provider names, and website details, then shortlist three to five Fishkill offices that fit your schedule, budget, and the care you need.
How does Dental.me rank Fishkill dentists?
By an independent Dental.me Score built from each practice's Google star rating out of 100, held to a confidence level by its review volume, with exact review counts breaking ties and a verification lift that lets confirmed practices reach a perfect 100. Featured placements are paid, clearly labeled, and never change the organic order.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.