Dentists in Fishers, IN: Local Guide

Quick answer: Fishers, IN has 84 dental practices in the Dental.me directory. 54 are rated on Google, averaging 4.83★ across 15,481 reviews. Top by independent Dental.me Score: Joseph Holland, Fishers Dental Care, CYNTHIA SCHUBBE BECKER DDS PC. Compare them below and shortlist two or three near you to call.

Start with the number that quietly reorganizes how you should shop for a dentist here: across the 54 rated practices in Fishers, not a single one sits below 4.0 stars. In most American cities of this size, a handful of low-rated offices act as a natural filter — you cross them off and move on. Fishers gives you no such shortcut. The floor of this market is high, which means the usual advice (“just avoid the bad ones”) is nearly useless. The real work in Fishers is not eliminating bad dentists. It is choosing among genuinely good ones.

That is a different kind of decision, and this guide is built for it. Everything below is drawn from Dental.me’s live record for Fishers dentists: 84 practices, a citywide average of 4.83 stars, and 15,481 Google reviews pooled across the offices that have earned enough feedback to be rated. That review volume — more than 15,000 opinions in a suburb this size — is what makes the signal here unusually trustworthy.

Why a 4.9 rating is the baseline here, not the badge of honor

In a weaker market, a 4.9-star office is a standout. In Fishers it is close to par. Of the 54 rated practices, 44 earn 4.8 stars or higher — that is roughly four out of five. Only four land in the 4.5–4.79 range, six sit between 4.0 and 4.49, and, again, none fall below 4.0. When the top tier is this crowded, the star rating alone stops separating the field. You have to read past the number.

The most-reviewed and the top-rated are not the same office

This is where Fishers gets interesting. The most-reviewed dentist in the city by a wide margin is Michael Talbott, carrying 2,351 reviews at 4.9 stars. That volume is a category of its own — it tells you a very large number of Fishers residents have reviewed the practice. Volume like that is hard to accumulate; it is the closest thing to a crowd verdict this market offers.

But the highest ratings belong elsewhere. Joseph Holland holds a perfect 5.0 across 864 reviews, and Fishers Dental Care matches that 5.0 over 792 reviews — two offices with both a flawless score and deep sample sizes, which is the combination that actually means something. A perfect five is easy to hold across a dozen reviews; holding it across hundreds is a genuinely different achievement, because the more people who weigh in, the harder it is to keep every single one satisfied. Just behind them, Teverbaugh4 LLC (4.9, 847 reviews) and Charles Sukurs (4.9, 611 reviews) round out the general-dentistry short list. Families with young children have a purpose-built option in Hoosier Pediatric Dental Group (4.9, 609 reviews), where the entire practice is oriented around kids rather than treating pediatric care as a sideline.

The practical takeaway: in Fishers, sort by rating × review depth together, never by either one alone. A useful mental shortcut is to mostly ignore any practice with fewer than about 100 reviews when you’re comparing them against offices that have thousands — not because the small ones are bad, but because you simply can’t tell yet. In a city this saturated with well-reviewed options, you rarely have to gamble on a thin sample.

The website gap is a scheduling clue

One number in the data is easy to skim past but genuinely useful: of the 84 listed practices, 54 have a website — and 54 is also the exact count of rated practices. In practice, a real online presence is where you can often find online booking, new-patient forms, service menus, and a way to check insurance before you call. The 30 or so practices without a website aren’t necessarily lower quality, but they’ll almost always require a phone call to learn anything, and they’re less likely to offer self-service scheduling. If your priority is booking fast and comparing services from your couch, start your shortlist among the offices that maintain a website; if you don’t mind picking up the phone, you can widen the net.

What Fishers is actually equipped to treat

A high-rated market still has to have the specialists you need. Fishers is broad. Cosmetic and restorative work is the deepest lane — 27 practices handle dental implants and 27 list cosmetic dentistry, with 15 offering teeth whitening. Alignment is well covered too, with 18 offices offering orthodontics and the same 18 providing Invisalign. The thinner lanes are the specialist referrals: 7 endodontists for root canals and just 6 oral surgeons, so it is worth calling those offices early. There is also a solid layer of gum-health care, with 15 periodontists and 13 dedicated pediatric dentists for children who need a specialist rather than a general family office. The pattern is typical of an affluent suburb: everyday and elective cosmetic services are abundant, while the surgical specialists are fewer and worth booking early. If you know you’ll need a specific procedure, check the specialty page first and let that shape which general dentist you pick, since Dental.me does not record which offices do that work themselves and which refer it out.

How to choose when everyone looks good on paper

Because the ratings compress at the top, your decision has to lean on the tiebreakers that ratings don’t show. Here is the sequence that works in a market like this one.

Step one screens for legitimacy: a 5.0 across 30 reviews is weaker evidence than a 4.9 across 2,000. Step two matters more here than in most cities because a top general dentist may not do the implant or root canal you specifically need — confirm the service is listed before you fall in love with the star rating. Step three is where a genuinely good office can still be the wrong one for you: verify your plan is accepted and that they are taking new patients. Step four is the only part a spreadsheet can’t do for you — a consult tells you whether the front desk, the wait time, and the chairside manner fit how you want to be treated.

Emergencies and same-day care

Fifteen Fishers practices list emergency dental services, which is solid coverage for a suburb of this size — but “emergency” means different things at different offices. What an office actually does for a cracked tooth or an abscess is a question for the first phone call. If you are choosing a primary dentist and you have kids or a history of dental trouble, ask about their after-hours policy on the first visit, not during the crisis. For a knocked-out or severely broken tooth, call first so they can prep the room before you arrive.

Looking just past the city line

Fishers sits inside one of the densest, highest-rated dental corridors in Indiana, so widening your search a few miles rarely means lowering your standards. Neighboring Carmel and Noblesville carry their own deep benches of well-reviewed offices, and McCordsville, Fortville, and Oaklandon are all short drives that can open up earlier appointment windows. If you need a rare specialist or an odd-hour slot, the greater Indianapolis market absorbs almost any request. Curious how these ratings are assembled and what they cost? Our national guide to dental costs lists what a quote depends on, so you know what to ask before you book.

Fishers is a rare market where the hard part isn’t finding a good dentist — it’s that there are too many. Use the data to narrow, then use a first visit to decide. When you’re ready, browse the full, continuously updated list of dentists in Fishers on Dental.me and start with the offices that pair a top rating with real review depth.

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.