Finding a good dentist in Fairport, New York starts with the numbers: Dental.me lists 29 practices across the village, 17 of them carry a star rating, and those rated offices average 4.94 stars across 2,525 reviews. Start with the six most-reviewed practices in the table below, and then match one to your own family’s needs.
The Fairport dental landscape at a glance
Dental.me lists 29 dental practices in Fairport. Of those, 17 carry a Google star rating, while the remaining 12 are listed without one. That does not make the unrated dozen worse offices; it means they have no rating on file, and Dental.me does not record why. It does mean that if you want to lean on ratings while you choose, you are working from a pool of 17.
The headline figure is the average. Those 17 rated Fairport practices average 4.94 stars, which sits at the very top of the five-star scale, and together they hold 2,525 reviews on file. That average is a plain mean of 17 ratings, so a 5.0 on one review counts as much as a 5.0 on 633. Thirteen of the 17 hold a 5.0, and five of those 13 rest on two reviews or fewer. The review weight sits with the six offices that each carry 100 or more reviews: together they hold 2,313 of the 2,525 (92%). Read each rating together with the review count behind it.
The most-reviewed dental practices in Fairport
The six offices below are Fairport’s six most-reviewed practices, listed by review count. Five of the six hold a perfect 5.0 and the sixth, Eastside Family Dental of Fairport, holds a 4.9, so within the table the main difference is how many people have weighed in. The table is not a list of every 5.0: eight other Fairport offices also hold a 5.0 on fewer reviews, including Spruce Grove Dental (65), Michael Mayer (27) and Patricia Stege (19); the other five rest on two reviews or fewer. Use the profile links to see each office’s full Dental.me listing.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zak & Vitagliano Dental PC | 5.0 | 633 | View profile |
| Smiles on the Canal Dentistry | 5.0 | 582 | View profile |
| Mary Ann Panara DDS and Jeffrey P Panara DDS | 5.0 | 445 | View profile |
| Brian Kritzman | 5.0 | 415 | View profile |
| Eastside Family Dental of Fairport, PC | 4.9 | 137 | View profile |
| Joseph T Loverdi DDS PLLC | 5.0 | 101 | View profile |
Notice how the top four separate on review volume: Zak & Vitagliano Dental PC and Smiles on the Canal Dentistry each pair a 5.0 with more than 500 reviews (633 and 582), while Mary Ann Panara DDS and Jeffrey P Panara DDS and Brian Kritzman hold theirs on 445 and 415 reviews. A 5.0 on 101 reviews at Joseph T Loverdi DDS PLLC rests on a smaller sample.
How Fairport’s ratings break down
The distribution behind that 4.94 average is top-heavy. Of the 17 rated practices, 16 land at 4.8 stars or higher, a single office falls in the 4.0 to 4.49 range, and nothing sits between 4.5 and 4.79 or below 4.0 at all. In practical terms, almost every rated dentist in Fairport clusters at the very top of the scale, so the choice is less about avoiding a weak score and more about weighing review volume, location within the village, and the services you actually need.
Website access and how to reach a Fairport practice
Every one of the 17 rated Fairport practices has a website URL on file, so you can look each one up online before you call. Dental.me does not record which insurance an office accepts. Ask the office directly. Across the full directory of 29, the count is 17 with a website URL on file and 12 without one recorded, so if you are working from the unrated group you may need to phone the office directly rather than start online. Having a URL on record is not a quality score in itself; it simply tells you a public web presence exists for the practice, which is one more way to confirm details before your first visit.
What review counts reveal in Fairport
Ratings tell you how people scored a practice; review counts tell you how much weight to put behind that score. Fairport’s 2,525 total reviews are concentrated in its four most-reviewed offices, which hold 2,075 of them (82%). Zak & Vitagliano leads with 633, followed by Smiles on the Canal at 582, the Panara practice at 445, and Brian Kritzman at 415. The chart below ranks the top six by review volume so you can see the drop-off: the front-runners each carry hundreds of entries, while Eastside Family Dental and Joseph T Loverdi DDS sit in the low hundreds. A larger count generally means a more stable, harder-to-move average, which is worth remembering when two offices show the same 5.0.
A 4.94 average and what it means for your search
An average this high across 17 offices leaves little room between offices on rating alone. It means the rated end of Fairport’s market is consistent (16 of the 17 sit at 4.8 or higher), so your decision rarely comes down to steering clear of a low rating. Instead, the practical differences are logistical: which office is closest to your home or work, which participates in your insurance, how soon each can see you, and whether you need general care or something more specialized. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you. A Google rating does not measure clinical quality. The gauge below places Fairport’s 4.94 on the full five-star scale.
Looking just beyond Fairport
Fairport’s own specialty pages list 4 orthodontists, 4 pediatric dentists, 3 endodontists, 2 oral surgeons, 2 periodontists and 1 emergency dentist, and none lists a prosthodontist. A list entry reflects the services a practice lists, not a specialist credential, so ask an office about its training. If no Fairport office fits your schedule, insurance, or the service you need, nearby directories add options. Pittsford lists 58 practices (31 rated), Penfield 21 (14 rated), East Rochester 6 (3 rated), Macedon 6 (3 rated) and Mendon 2 (both rated). Webster lists 40 (27 rated) and Rochester 414 (202 rated). Start with the Fairport listings on the Fairport city hub, then expand outward only if you need a specific service, a particular insurance network, or an earlier appointment. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are in Fairport, NY?
Dental.me lists 29 dental practices in Fairport. Of those, 17 currently carry a star rating and 12 are listed without one. Dental.me does not record why a practice has no rating.
What is the highest-rated dentist in Fairport?
Thirteen of the 17 rated offices hold a 5.0, five of them on two reviews or fewer. Ranked by review volume behind that score, Zak & Vitagliano Dental PC leads with 633 reviews, followed by Smiles on the Canal Dentistry at 582 and Mary Ann Panara DDS and Jeffrey P Panara DDS at 445.
What is the average dentist rating in Fairport?
Across the 17 rated practices, the average is 4.94 stars out of 5, built on a combined 2,525 reviews. Sixteen of those 17 offices sit at 4.8 stars or higher.
Do Fairport dental practices list a website?
All 17 rated practices have a website URL on file. Across the full directory of 29, 17 have a URL recorded and 12 do not, so for the unrated offices you may need to call the practice directly to confirm details.
How should I choose between two five-star Fairport dentists?
When ratings tie, look at review volume, location, and services. A 5.0 backed by 633 reviews rests on a larger sample than a 5.0 backed by 101, and factors like proximity and insurance participation can decide the rest.
Are there good dentists near Fairport if I can’t find a fit?
Nearby directories add options: Pittsford lists 58 practices, Penfield 21, East Rochester 6, Macedon 6 and Mendon 2, and Rochester lists 414.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.