Home › Dental Guides › Dentists in Dyer, IN: Local Guide

Dentists in Dyer, IN: Local Guide

Published June 30, 2026 · dental.me editorial · How we verify

Dental.me lists 23 dental practices in Dyer, Indiana, and 15 of them carry a Google rating. Those 15 average 4.61 stars across 1,317 reviews. This guide lists the highest-rated offices, sets out which of Dental.me's service lists hold a Dyer office, and points to the nearby directories.

How Dyer’s dental landscape breaks down

Fifteen of the 23 Dyer practices carry a Google rating, and together they hold 1,317 reviews at an average of 4.61. Those ratings rest on anywhere from 3 reviews to 315, and half rest on 52 or fewer. The other eight carry no rating and no reviews on file; Dental.me does not record why. Sixteen practices have a website URL on file, 13 of them rated.

A Google rating and a review count are third-party figures; neither measures clinical quality. The sections below sort the rated offices and show which service lists hold a Dyer office, so you can shortlist two or three and call them.

The highest-rated practices in Dyer

The table lists the six highest-rated Dyer practices with at least 20 reviews, sorted by Google rating and then by review count. John Valesano holds a 5.0 on 44 reviews, and Advanced Dental and Anthony Dicostanzo DDS PC hold a 4.9 on 315 and 228, the two largest review counts in Dyer. Three more Dyer offices hold a 5.0 on fewer reviews: Dental Cure – Dyer (17), JH Orthodontics, Inc (10) and Chris J Morfas, PC (3).

Practice Rating Reviews Profile
John Valesano 5.0 44 View profile
Advanced Dental 4.9 315 View profile
Anthony Dicostanzo DDS PC 4.9 228 View profile
John Gutterman 4.8 211 View profile
Ellis Orthodontics, LLC 4.8 52 View profile
Illiana Endodontics, P.C. 4.7 155 View profile

The same rating can rest on very different samples: John Valesano's 5.0 rests on 44 reviews and Advanced Dental's 4.9 on 315. A rating on a handful of reviews can move with each new one, so read the review count beside each rating. By Dental.me Score the order is Advanced Dental, Anthony Dicostanzo, John Gutterman, John Valesano, Ellis Orthodontics and Illiana Endodontics: the same six offices as the table, in a different order. The chart shows the six largest review counts, which together hold 1,097 of Dyer's 1,317 reviews (83%); two of them, Michael Gideon (4.6 on 132) and David Arnold (3.7 on 56), are not in the table.

Dyer's six largest Google review counts Advanced Dental · 4.9★ 315 Anthony Dicostanzo DDS PC · 4.9★ 228 John Gutterman · 4.8★ 211 Illiana Endodontics · 4.7★ 155 Michael Gideon · 4.6★ 132 David Arnold · 3.7★ 56 Bar length = Google review count. A review count is not a measure of clinical quality.

Reading Dyer’s rating distribution

Of the 15 rated Dyer practices, eight are rated 4.8 or higher, three 4.5 to 4.79, two 4.0 to 4.49 and two below 4.0. Three of the eight at 4.8 or higher rest on 17 reviews or fewer. The two below 4.0 are David Arnold (3.7 on 56) and Jethroe Smith (3.7 on 3); leave those two out and the other 13 average 4.75.

Where the 15 rated offices land 4.8+ stars 8 4.5–4.79 3 4.0–4.49 2 Under 4.0 2 Count of rated practices in each rating band

The four practices rated below 4.5 are worth a closer read of their profiles before you rule them in or out. A rating does not tell you whether an office takes your insurance or whether it does your procedure itself. Dental.me does not record which insurance an office accepts.

Website coverage and what it tells you

Of Dyer's 23 practices, 16 have a website URL on file, including 13 of the 15 rated practices. A website often lets you check services and new-patient forms before you call.

Website URL on file: 16 of 23 16 on file 7 Filled bar = practices with a website URL recorded

The 7 practices without a URL recorded are not necessarily worse offices — the record simply reflects what is on file, not the quality of care. For those, a phone call is your first point of contact rather than a website visit, so budget an extra step when you reach out.

Specialty care available in Dyer

Eleven of Dental.me's 12 service lists hold at least one Dyer office: teeth whitening 8, cosmetic dentists 8, dental implants 5, pediatric dentists 4, orthodontists 4, Invisalign 4, periodontists 3, dentures 3, endodontists 3, emergency dentists 2, prosthodontists 1. The oral-surgeon list holds none. The orthodontist and Invisalign lists hold the same four offices, among them Ellis Orthodontics and JH Orthodontics, and Illiana Endodontics is one of the three on the endodontist list. One office can sit on several lists. A place on a list shows what an office lists, not how often it does that work, so ask whether the office does your procedure itself.

Dyer practices on each service list Teeth whitening 8 Cosmetic dentists 8 Dental implants 5 Pediatric dentists 4 Orthodontists 4 Invisalign 4 Periodontists 3 Dentures 3 Endodontists 3 Emergency dentists 2 Prosthodontists 1 Oral surgeons 0 Bar length = number of Dyer practices on each Dental.me service list.

If you know the treatment you need, start from the list for it rather than the general directory, and check which of the rated offices above are on it. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.

Nearby directories

Nearby communities have their own Dental.me directories: Munster (74 practices, 42 rated), Schererville (43 practices, 24 rated), St. John (10 practices, 6 rated). Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live.

Munster lists 74 practices and Schererville 43, against 23 in Dyer; St. John lists 10. Each directory uses the same Google rating and review-count figures.

How to choose, and how the Dental.me Score works

Start on the Dyer dental directory, check the service list for the work you need, and shortlist two or three practices. Dental.me holds posted hours for 16 of the 23 Dyer practices and a phone number for all 23. Then call to ask about insurance, cost and how soon the office can see you.

The star ratings here are the Google ratings on file, and no office can pay Dental.me to change them. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. The only thing money changes is Featured placement, which is labeled wherever it appears; it never changes a rating, a Score or the order of a rating-based table like the one above.

Frequently asked questions

How many dentists are there in Dyer, Indiana?

Dental.me tracks 23 dental practices in Dyer. Of those, 15 carry a public rating, and together those rated offices hold 1,317 reviews at an average of 4.61 stars.

Which dentist in Dyer has the highest rating?

Four Dyer practices hold a 5.0 Google rating: John Valesano on 44 reviews, Dental Cure – Dyer on 17, JH Orthodontics on 10 and Chris J Morfas on 3. Advanced Dental and Anthony Dicostanzo DDS PC hold a 4.9 on the two largest review counts in Dyer, 315 and 228. By Dental.me Score, Advanced Dental is first.

Are there specialty dentists in Dyer?

Eleven of Dental.me's 12 service lists hold at least one Dyer office. The cosmetic-dentist and teeth-whitening lists hold eight each, dental implants five, and the orthodontist, Invisalign and pediatric-dentist lists four each; the oral-surgeon list holds none. A place on a list shows what an office lists, so ask whether it does your procedure itself.

Do Dyer dental practices have websites?

Of Dyer’s 23 practices, 16 have a website URL on file, including 13 of the 15 rated ones. For the 7 without a URL recorded, a phone call is your first point of contact.

What towns near Dyer also have dentists?

Dental.me has directories for nearby Munster (74 practices, 42 rated), Schererville (43 practices, 24 rated) and St. John (10 practices, 6 rated). Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live.

Can a dentist pay to rank higher on Dental.me?

No. The Dental.me Score is earned from public data and cannot be bought. The only element that can be paid for is a Featured placement, which is clearly labeled and does not change a practice’s score or its position in a rating-based ranking.

Find a dentist near you on dental.me. Compare practice details, hours, ratings, and the Dental.me Score across the directory.
Browse Indiana dentists   More dental guides →

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.