Home › Dental Guides › Dentists in Carlisle, PA: Local Guide

Dentists in Carlisle, PA: Local Guide

Published June 30, 2026 · dental.me editorial · How we verify

Carlisle, Pennsylvania has 28 dental practices in the Dental.me directory, and 17 carry a Google rating that averages 4.77 out of five across 3,475 reviews. Thirteen of the 17 sit at 4.8 or higher, so read each rating next to the review count behind it. This guide lists the highest-rated offices and shows how the borough's reviews are distributed.

Carlisle is the seat of Cumberland County. More than half of the practices on file here carry a published star rating (17 of 28), and together they hold 3,475 reviews. Below, we break down what those figures mean for someone choosing a dentist, name the highest-rated offices, and cover all 12 service lists and the nearby directories. The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. A paid Featured placement does not change a practice’s rating or Score. The Carlisle hub does show four listings marked Featured first. Ratings are third-party Google data: they show how reviewers scored an office, not its clinical quality.

The short version: five Carlisle practices hold a 5.0 star rating, two of them on more than 300 reviews each and three on 11 or fewer, and five more are rated 4.9. Every office in the table below has a profile and a website URL you can check before you call. The largest review record in town is Noll Family Dentistry (4.9 on 1,080); the second-largest, Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. (4.8 on 602), sits outside the table. The rest of this guide explains how to read those ratings, which services the lists cover, and how the borough compares with nearby directories.

Carlisle’s dentists by the numbers

Of the 28 practices Dental.me tracks in Carlisle, 17 carry a star rating, and 15 of those 17 also have a website URL on file (two unrated practices list one as well). Thirteen of the 17 are rated 4.8 or higher; one lands between 4.5 and 4.79 (Allyn Perkins, 4.7 on 41); two fall between 4.0 and 4.49 (Thomas Appleby 4.4 and Smile Rite II 4.3, on 11 reviews each); and one is rated below 4.0 (David Killian, 3.8 on 39). Three of the 13 top-band ratings rest on 11 reviews or fewer.

Rated practices by rating band 4.8 and up 4.5 – 4.79 4.0 – 4.49 Under 4.0 13 1 2 1 13 of 17 rated Carlisle practices are rated 4.8 or higher

Of the 17 rated practices in Carlisle, 15 also have a website URL on file, so you can research most scored offices online before booking. The chart below frames that against the full set of 28 tracked practices: 17 are rated (15 of them with a website URL on file), while 11 remain on file without a rating yet.

Rated practices 17 of 28 17 rated 11 tracked, not yet rated Rated coverage: about 61% of tracked practices

The highest-rated dental practices in Carlisle

The table below lists the six highest-rated Carlisle practices with at least 100 reviews, listed by star rating and then by review count. Five Carlisle practices hold a 5.0; two of them clear that 100-review bar, and the other three rest on 11 reviews or fewer: Joseph Bourdon (11), Valley Advanced Orthodontics (9) and Dennis Burkett (6). Every office in the table is rated at least 4.9. On the same rule, Wood & Myers Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery (4.9 on 159) comes seventh and Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. (4.8 on 602) eighth. Each practice name links to its full Dental.me profile.

Practice Rating Reviews Profile
Serafin Family Dentistry LLC 5.0 353 View profile
Richard Cantor 5.0 340 View profile
Noll Family Dentistry 4.9 1,080 View profile
Carlisle Dental Studio P.C. 4.9 228 View profile
George W. Blashford, DMD, PC 4.9 214 View profile
Straight Smile Studio 4.9 186 View profile

Serafin Family Dentistry LLC and Richard Cantor share the top of the table on rating, each holding a 5.0, on 353 and 340 reviews. Noll Family Dentistry sits just behind on rating at 4.9 but holds the largest review record in town, 1,080, more than the next three offices in the table combined. The chart below puts those six review totals on one scale; it leaves out the second-largest record, Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. (4.8 on 602).

Reviews behind the table six Noll Family Serafin Family Richard Cantor Carlisle Dental Studio George W. Blashford Straight Smile Studio 1,080 353 340 228 214 186 These six hold 2,401 of 3,475 reviews

How the Dental.me Score works

The ratings in this guide are Google star ratings. Dental.me also gives each practice a Dental.me Score, built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. It is earned from what the data shows, never purchased. The Carlisle hub does open with four listings marked Featured, shown out of Score order; after those it follows the Score. A Featured placement does not change a practice’s position in the table above.

This matters in a market like Carlisle’s, where ratings cluster tightly at the top. When 13 of 17 rated offices sit at 4.8 or above, a raw star average alone barely separates them. Review volume tells you how much evidence sits behind a number: a 4.9 built on 1,080 reviews, as at Noll Family Dentistry, rests on far more feedback than a 4.9 drawn from a couple of hundred. You can see each practice’s rating, review count and office details on its profile, and browse every tracked office from the Carlisle dentist directory.

Specialty care in Carlisle: implants, orthodontics, and cosmetic dentistry

Beyond general and family dentistry, Carlisle's practices appear on Dental.me's service lists. A practice is on a list when it lists that service; it does not mean each is a specialist. Teeth whitening has 8 offices, cosmetic dentists 7, dental implants 6, and orthodontists and Invisalign 5 each (the same five). Periodontists and emergency dentists list 3 each; pediatric dentists and oral surgeons 2 each; endodontists and dentures 1 each; the prosthodontist list is empty, so 11 of the 12 lists name at least one office. The seven cosmetic offices are all on the whitening list. Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. is on 7 of the 12 lists, more than any other office; David Killian is on 6, and Noll Family Dentistry and Wood & Myers on 5 each.

Practices offering each specialty Teeth whitening Cosmetic dentistry Dental implants Orthodontists 8 7 6 5 Counts reflect practices listing each service in Carlisle

If you are weighing a specific procedure, start from the specialty page rather than the full directory. You can compare every office that lists the service on the Carlisle dental implants page, review aesthetic providers on the cosmetic dentistry page, or look at whitening options on the teeth whitening page. It is worth checking whether a highly rated general office also lists the specialty you need before booking a separate provider.

How to choose among Carlisle’s top-rated dentists

With all six table offices between 4.9 and 5.0, the table alone will not make the decision for you. Start by matching the practice to what you need: for routine and family care, the general and family offices in the table are a starting point, and four of the six also appear on at least one service list. If you know you need implants, orthodontics or a cosmetic procedure, open the relevant service page first and see which of the top-rated offices appears there.

Location is the next filter. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route. From there, confirm the practical details a rating cannot capture – whether the office takes your insurance and its hours – before you commit. All 28 practices have a phone number on file and 16 have hours on the Dental.me profile. Of the 17 rated practices, 15 have a website URL on file. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.

Finally, weigh the rating against its evidence base. A 5.0 on a handful of reviews has told you less than one on hundreds; the table only admits offices with at least 100 reviews, so the three 5.0s on 11, 9 and 6 reviews sit outside it. When two practices look otherwise equal, weigh review depth and service coverage, and use the nearby directories below if you want more choices.

Where Carlisle’s reviews concentrate

The 3,475 reviews across Carlisle's rated practices are not spread evenly. Noll Family Dentistry alone accounts for 1,080 of them (31%), Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. holds 602, and the three largest records together carry 2,035, 59% of the total. A large review count moves less when one new rating arrives than a small one does. Dental.me holds no review dates, so it cannot tell you how recent a rating is.

Serafin Family Dentistry LLC and Richard Cantor both hold 5.0 ratings on more than 300 reviews each. The practical takeaway is to read the rating and the review count together rather than treating a single number in isolation: in Carlisle, three more 5.0s rest on 11, 9 and 6 reviews, where one new rating can move the figure.

It is also worth remembering that the four lower-rated practices – the one office in the 4.5-to-4.79 band, the two between 4.0 and 4.49, and the single office below 4.0 – are a small minority of the rated field. And 11 tracked practices carry no star rating yet, so it is worth checking the directory again if none of the offices in the table is the right fit.

Looking just beyond Carlisle

If the borough's own offices do not fit your insurance network or the service you need, nearby directories widen the search. Mechanicsburg lists 56 practices (33 rated), double Carlisle's 28. The others are small: Dillsburg lists 5 (4 rated), Newville 2 (none rated), and Boiling Springs and Shermans Dale 1 each (each rated). Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.

Each directory uses the same Dental.me data as Carlisle's, so you can compare offices across town lines on one measure. Carlisle's own list holds 17 rated practices, 13 of them at 4.8 or higher.

Frequently asked questions

How many dentists are in Carlisle, PA?

Dental.me tracks 28 dental practices in Carlisle. Of those, 17 carry a published star rating, and those rated offices average 4.77 out of five. Of those 17 rated practices, 15 also have a website URL on file.

Which dentist in Carlisle has the highest rating?

Five Carlisle practices hold a perfect 5.0 star rating. Serafin Family Dentistry LLC (353 reviews) and Richard Cantor (340 reviews) carry by far the most reviews among them; Joseph Bourdon (11), Valley Advanced Orthodontics (9) and Dennis Burkett (6) rest on far fewer. Five more offices are rated 4.9.

What is the most-reviewed dental practice in Carlisle?

Noll Family Dentistry carries the most reviews of any Carlisle office, 1,080 (about 31% of the 3,475 reviews across all rated practices), at a 4.9 rating. Flenniken & Flenniken P.C. is second with 602, at 4.8.

Can I find a dentist in Carlisle for implants, braces, or cosmetic work?

Yes. In Carlisle, eight practices list teeth whitening, seven list cosmetic dentistry, six list dental implants, and five list orthodontics (the same five list Invisalign). Eleven of Dental.me's 12 service lists for the borough name at least one office. The service pages let you compare only the offices that list the service you need.

What is the Dental.me Score, and can a dentist pay for it?

The Dental.me Score is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. It is earned, not purchased; only a Featured placement can be paid for, and it does not change a practice’s rating or Score.

Where can I find dentists near Carlisle if none fit?

Mechanicsburg is the largest nearby directory, with 56 practices (33 rated). Dillsburg lists 5 (4 rated), Newville 2 (none rated), and Boiling Springs and Shermans Dale 1 each. Dental.me does not measure drive times, so check each address against your route.

Find a dentist near you on dental.me. Compare practice details, hours, ratings, and the Dental.me Score across the directory.
Browse Pennsylvania dentists   More dental guides →

Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.