Bainbridge Island lists 27 dental practices in the Dental.me directory, and 14 of them carry a public rating that averages 4.73 out of five. To find a good one, start with that rated group, compare review volume alongside the score, and confirm the practice is currently accepting new patients before you book.
What the island’s dental directory actually holds
Bainbridge Island sits in Puget Sound, across the water from downtown Seattle and connected to the Kitsap Peninsula by State Route 305 over the Agate Pass Bridge near Poulsbo. That geography matters: the 27 practices on the island are not spread across a sprawling metro but concentrated in and around Winslow and the SR 305 corridor. That makes the directory easy to work through end to end.
Of those 27 practices, 14 carry a public rating. The other 13 are listed but not yet rated, which does not make them worse offices, only quieter ones in the data. Across the rated group the average is 4.73 out of five, and the 14 rated practices have drawn 372 reviews between them. Thirteen of the 27 have a website URL on file. Those four numbers, 27 listed, 14 rated, 4.73 average, and 372 total reviews, are the frame for everything below, and the charts throughout this guide are built only from them.
The highest-rated practices on Bainbridge Island
The table below ranks the island’s rated practices by their star rating, with review count breaking any tie. It is worth reading both columns together: a perfect 5.0 on a handful of reviews and a 4.9 on 170 reviews describe very different things, and a careful choice weighs the score against how many people stand behind it.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mark Soltys | 5.0 | 7 | View profile |
| Bainbridge Dental | 5.0 | 4 | View profile |
| Todd Adams | 4.9 | 170 | View profile |
| Fairy Tale Dental | 4.7 | 63 | View profile |
| Josiah Clements | 4.7 | 31 | View profile |
| Dr Andrew L Fiscus DDS PC | 4.5 | 20 | View profile |
Two practices, Mark Soltys and Bainbridge Dental, sit at a flat 5.0, though each on fewer than ten reviews. Todd Adams holds a 4.9 across 170 reviews, by far the largest review base on the island, which is why a slightly lower score there carries more statistical weight than a perfect one built on four. Fairy Tale Dental and Josiah Clements both show 4.7, and Dr Andrew L Fiscus DDS PC rounds out the ranked group at 4.5.
How the ratings distribute across the island
The 14 rated practices cluster high. Seven of them, exactly half, score 4.8 or above; four land in the 4.5 to 4.79 band; three fall between 4.0 and 4.49; and none sit below 4.0. That shape is the practical meaning of a 4.73 island average, and it is why the chart below has no bar at the bottom.
For someone choosing quickly, this is reassuring: on the rated side of the directory there is no bottom tier to steer around. The real decision is among highly rated offices, not between high and low ratings. That said, half the island’s practices have no rating yet, so a high average across the rated group is a statement about the offices that have been reviewed, not a verdict on the ones that have not.
Website coverage across the directory
Thirteen of the 27 listed practices have a website URL on file, which is roughly 48 percent, or a little under half. For the other 14 there is no website URL recorded, so reaching them may mean using the phone number or the details on the practice profile rather than looking for an online booking page.
A missing website URL is a note about the directory record, not a judgment on the office. Some of the island’s practices simply have not published or shared a site. When a listing shows no URL, the practice profile is still the fastest way to see its rating and review history, and a phone call remains the surest way to confirm hours, insurance, and whether new patients are being taken.
Where the island’s reviews are concentrated
The 372 reviews across the rated group are far from evenly spread. Todd Adams alone accounts for 170 of them, and the six ranked practices in the table together hold 295, leaving 77 spread across the remaining eight rated offices. The chart below shows how lopsided that distribution is.
Review volume is not the same as quality, but it changes how much confidence a score carries. Todd Adams keeps a 4.9 while carrying more reviews than the next five ranked practices combined, which is a hard thing to do; a rating tends to drift toward the middle as the sample grows. At the other end, the two 5.0 practices are backed by 7 and 4 reviews, so their scores are genuinely perfect but rest on a much smaller base. Neither pattern is a red mark. It simply tells you which numbers to trust literally and which to read as early signals.
The island average at a glance
Pulling the rated group together, the single figure to remember is 4.73 out of five. On a zero-to-five scale that places the island’s typical rated practice comfortably in the upper range, closer to the top of the scale than to its midpoint.
Averages hide the spread, which is why it helps to read this gauge next to the band chart above. The 4.73 is not a single crowd of practices clustered on one point; it is seven offices at 4.8-plus pulling the number up and three in the 4.0 to 4.49 band holding it down. Knowing that, you can treat 4.73 as a floor for your expectations of the island’s top tier rather than a ceiling.
Looking off the island: Kitsap and Seattle
Twenty-seven practices is a healthy roster for one island, but if you want more choice, more specialty options, or an office closer to work rather than home, the surrounding area opens up quickly. Head across the Agate Pass Bridge on SR 305 and you reach dental practices in Poulsbo. Further into Kitsap County, the directories for Silverdale, Bremerton, and Port Orchard each list their own practices with their own ratings.
Across Puget Sound, the ferry from Winslow lands in downtown Seattle, so the much larger Seattle dental directory is within reach for anyone already making that crossing. Each of those city pages carries the same rating, review-count, and website data used throughout this guide, so you can compare an off-island option against a Bainbridge practice on identical terms. When you want the full picture for the island itself, the Bainbridge Island directory hub lists every one of the 27 practices, rated and unrated alike.
A step-by-step way to choose
Start narrow, then widen only if you need to. First, work from the rated group: 14 of the 27 practices carry a public rating, and that is the most decision-ready information the directory holds. Second, read the score and the review count together rather than sorting on stars alone. Todd Adams at 4.9 across 170 reviews and Mark Soltys at 5.0 across 7 are both strong, but they earn your confidence in different ways, one through a high rating at scale and the other through a smaller, spotless record.
Third, open two or three practice profiles and check the details that a rating cannot show you, insurance accepted, whether they are taking new patients, and the treatments they list. If a practice has no website URL on file, use the phone number on its profile to confirm those things directly. Fourth, if nothing on the island fits, cross to Poulsbo, Silverdale, Bremerton, Port Orchard, or Seattle using the links above. Because every listing is scored the same way, you never have to guess how an off-island practice stacks up against a Bainbridge one. The Dental.me Score is earned from a practice’s public signals, never sold, so a higher place in these rankings reflects the record, not a payment.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are on Bainbridge Island?
The Dental.me directory lists 27 dental practices on Bainbridge Island, 14 of which currently carry a public rating. The remaining 13 are listed but not yet rated, which reflects the data rather than the quality of the office.
Which Bainbridge Island practice has the highest rating?
Mark Soltys and Bainbridge Dental both show a perfect 5.0, though on smaller review counts of 7 and 4. Todd Adams holds a 4.9 across 170 reviews, by far the largest review base on the island.
What is the average dentist rating on Bainbridge Island?
Across the 14 rated practices the average is 4.73 out of five. Seven of those practices sit at 4.8 or higher, four fall between 4.5 and 4.79, three land between 4.0 and 4.49, and none are below 4.0.
How do I reach a Bainbridge Island dentist from Seattle?
Bainbridge Island is reached from downtown Seattle by the Washington State Ferries route to Winslow. From the Kitsap Peninsula, State Route 305 crosses the Agate Pass Bridge near Poulsbo onto the island.
Do Bainbridge Island dental practices list a website?
Thirteen of the 27 listed practices have a website URL on file, a little under half. For the other 14 there is no URL recorded, so the practice profile or a phone call is the best way to find contact details.
Are there more dentist options near Bainbridge Island?
Yes. Nearby Kitsap communities including Poulsbo, Silverdale, Bremerton, and Port Orchard each have their own directory pages, and Seattle is a ferry ride across Puget Sound with a much larger set of practices.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.