Finding a good dentist in Amsterdam, New York means working through the 30 dental practices listed across the city, of which 13 carry a published star rating that averages 3.77. Start with the highest-rated offices in the table below, weigh each rating against its review count, and confirm the practice fits your family’s needs.
Amsterdam’s 30 listings are few enough to compare one by one, and this guide does that. It works only from Dental.me’s recorded figures for the city, so every number below is one you can check against a practice’s own profile.
How Amsterdam’s dental options break down
Of the 30 practices listed in Amsterdam, 13 have a Google rating; the other 17 hold no Google reviews in Dental.me’s data. The 13 hold 654 reviews between them and average 3.77 stars. Seven of the 13 sit below 4.0, and that band pulls the average down. Seven practices have a website URL on file, and six are on the dental implants list. When you compare Amsterdam offices, read a star rating alongside the number of reviews behind it: a 5.0 on one review and a 4.8 on 249 are not telling you the same thing.
The table below lists the six practices at the top of the Dental.me Score order, re-sorted by star rating and then by review count. In Score order they run Siriravali Dental Care PC, Vincent Giaimo, Perth Dental Office, Maya Gurme, Robert J. Dunning D.D.S., P.C. and Chelsea Morini. Each name links to its full Amsterdam profile.
| Practice | Rating | Reviews | Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Robert J. Dunning D.D.S., P.C. | 5.0 | 1 | View profile |
| Siriravali Dental Care PC | 4.8 | 249 | View profile |
| Vincent Giaimo | 4.8 | 117 | View profile |
| Perth Dental Office | 4.7 | 23 | View profile |
| Maya Gurme | 4.7 | 11 | View profile |
| Chelsea Morini | 4.1 | 21 | View profile |
The top-rated practices, read in context
Robert J. Dunning D.D.S., P.C. shows a 5.0, but that rating rests on a single review. It sits at the top of the rating-sorted table, and one more review could move it in either direction. The two offices that pair a high rating with a larger record are Siriravali Dental Care PC, at 4.8 on 249 reviews, and Vincent Giaimo, also 4.8 on 117. Together they hold 366 of the city’s 654 reviews (56%).
Perth Dental Office and Maya Gurme both hold 4.7, on 23 and 11 reviews, a thinner sample than the two above. Chelsea Morini completes the six at 4.1 on 21 reviews. These six are the only Amsterdam offices rated 4.0 or higher, and they range from a 5.0 on one review to a 4.8 on 249.
The 17 practices still without a rating
Subtract the 13 rated offices from the 30 on file and 17 remain without a Google rating. That is not a verdict: a listing carries no rating when no Google reviews are on file, and the directory records the gap, not the reason for it. For an unrated listing you will be relying on a phone call and your own questions rather than a published rating. Hours are posted for 10 of the 30 listings.
Reading the ratings across the whole city
The 3.77 city average hides a split. Among the 13 rated practices, three sit at 4.8 or higher, two land in the 4.5-to-4.79 range, one falls between 4.0 and 4.49, and seven come in below 4.0. More than half of Amsterdam’s rated offices hold under four stars, and those seven are not all small records: they include two of the city’s four largest, Theodore Edwards (3.0 on 118) and William Bresonis (1.9 on 56). Together the seven hold 232 reviews. The chart below shows the distribution.
What does the 3.77 mean for your search? Mostly that you should not take the citywide figure as your expected experience. Averages fold every rated office together, strong and weak, heavily reviewed and barely reviewed. The number to plan around is the score of the specific practice you book, read next to how many reviews stand behind it. In Amsterdam that reframes the whole field: the headline says 3.77, but six practices sit at 4.0 or higher and two of them hold 4.8 on triple-digit review counts. The gap between the average and the top is the entire reason to compare offices individually instead of assuming the city’s midpoint is your fate.
Website coverage and reaching an office
Seven of Amsterdam’s 30 listed practices have a website URL on file; the other 23 do not. Six of the seven belong to rated offices. A missing URL does not mean an office has no web presence, only that Dental.me has no link recorded for it, but it changes how you make first contact. For the 23 without a URL on file, plan to phone the office to confirm hours, insurance and whether it can see you as a new patient. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you.
Translate that split into a plan. For a practice with a URL on file, your first ten minutes can happen online: confirm the address, scan the listed services, and see whether online booking exists. For the 23 without one, budget a phone call instead, and keep the practice’s Dental.me profile open while you dial so you can match what you are told against the rating and review count on the page.
Where the review feedback concentrates
Amsterdam’s 654 recorded reviews are not spread evenly. The six largest records hold 593 of them (91%): Siriravali Dental Care PC (4.8 on 249), Theodore Edwards (3.0 on 118), Vincent Giaimo (4.8 on 117), William Bresonis (1.9 on 56), Family Dentistry and Denture Services LLP (3.2 on 30) and Perth Dental Office (4.7 on 23). Siriravali’s 249 is more than double the next record. A rating built on hundreds of reviews tends to be stable, while one resting on a handful can shift quickly, so let the bar lengths below temper how much weight you give each star figure.
This concentration matters for how you read the rest of the field. A large record can sit at either end of the scale: Siriravali and Vincent Giaimo hold 4.8 on 249 and 117 reviews, while Theodore Edwards holds 3.0 on 118. The 4.7 pair, Perth Dental Office and Maya Gurme, rest on 23 and 11 reviews, so a handful of new reviews could move either figure. Robert J. Dunning’s 5.0 rests on one review, which is why it leads the rating-sorted table without leading on review depth. Read the star and the count together.
Specialty care: dental implants in Amsterdam
Dental implants is Amsterdam’s longest service list: six of the 30 practices are on it, and you can browse them together on the Amsterdam dental implants page. The oral-surgeon list holds four listings, and the teeth-whitening, cosmetic and dentures lists two each. The pediatric, orthodontist and Invisalign lists hold one each, and the periodontist, endodontist, emergency and prosthodontist lists are empty. For routine care, the full roster on the Amsterdam city hub is the place to start.
With one in five listed practices on the implants list, you have a small set to choose from, and most offices in town do not list the service, so confirm it directly if implants are the reason for your search. A place on a list shows what an office lists, not how often it does that work, so ask whether the office does your procedure itself. If none of the six suits your schedule or insurance, the nearby-towns section below lists other directories.
A first-visit checklist for Amsterdam
Before you commit to any of the 30 practices, run the same short check on each candidate. Ask whether the office can see you as a new patient. Dental.me holds no availability data, so call to ask how soon an office can see you. Ask which insurance plans it takes, and whether it offers a payment option if you are paying out of pocket. Check that the services you need are on its list, whether that is a routine cleaning, a crown, pediatric care, or one of the six implant listings in town. Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live. Finally, match the answers against the rating and review figures in the table before you book.
Looking just beyond Amsterdam
Several nearby towns have their own Dental.me directories: Gloversville lists 13 practices (7 rated), Johnstown 8 (6 rated), Fonda 2, Broadalbin 1 and Charlton 1. Each lists fewer practices than Amsterdam’s 30. Dental.me holds no drive-time data, so check the distance from where you live.
How to choose an Amsterdam dentist
Put the pieces together in order. First, use the rating band chart: six Amsterdam offices hold 4.0 or higher. Second, check each candidate’s review count, treating a high rating on hundreds of reviews as firmer than the same rating on one or two. Third, confirm the practical details: whether the office has a website URL on file or needs a phone call, whether it lists the service you need, such as implants, and how soon it can see you as a new patient. The Dental.me Score that orders each city hub is built mainly from a practice’s Google rating and the depth of reviews behind it, with a small lift for an office that verifies its listing. The final call, matched to your insurance and your schedule, is yours to make from the profiles.
Frequently asked questions
How many dentists are in Amsterdam, NY?
Dental.me lists 30 dental practices in Amsterdam. Of those, 13 carry a published star rating, and those rated offices average 3.77 stars across 654 total reviews.
Which Amsterdam dental practice has the most reviews?
Siriravali Dental Care PC, with 249 reviews at a 4.8 rating, the largest record in Amsterdam. The next two are Theodore Edwards (118 reviews, 3.0) and Vincent Giaimo (117 reviews, 4.8).
What is the highest-rated dentist in Amsterdam?
Robert J. Dunning D.D.S., P.C. shows a 5.0, but from a single review. Among practices with substantial feedback, Siriravali Dental Care PC and Vincent Giaimo both hold 4.8, on 249 and 117 reviews.
How many Amsterdam practices offer dental implants?
Six of the 30 listed Amsterdam practices note dental implants among their services. You can view that shortlist together on the Amsterdam dental implants page.
How many Amsterdam dentists have a website on file?
Seven of the 30 listed practices have a website URL on file with Dental.me. For the other 23, no URL is recorded, so a phone call is the direct way to reach the office.
Where can I look for a dentist near Amsterdam?
Nearby directories include Gloversville (13 listed practices), Johnstown (8), Fonda (2), Broadalbin (1) and Charlton (1). Each lists fewer practices than Amsterdam.
Dental.me organizes dental directory data so patients can compare offices with confidence. Use each practice profile and its available website, map, and phone details for current appointment, payment, and care decisions.